UPDATED WITH SCANS ----- Sub / Review Results.....1 outta 15 - oh well. but a low Pop 9
balco758
Posts: 1,314 ✭✭✭✭✭
Submitted 15 for review as part of my membership renewal. Had hoped to hit on 1 of the 3 76 Brett's but no such luck for the 8.5. The Stengel is a nice card - was an 8 and thought 8.5 was possible but excited for a 9!!
Just wanted to share with the board. Thanks guys.
Steve
Total Items: 15
Date Received: 8/31/2017
Date Shipped: 9/14/2017
Tracking Number: 9210890163776901970492
Order Status: Processing
Line #1Item #1Cert #19727933 Grade NEAR MINT-MINT 8 Description 1980 Topps Scoring Leader Bird,Erving,Johnson TypeCard
Line #2Item #1Cert #40623121 Grade MINT 9 Description 1952 Bowman 217 Casey Stengel TypeCard
Line #3Item #1Cert #19765764 Grade NEAR MINT-MINT 8 Description 1954 Topps 17 Phil Rizzuto TypeCard
Line #4Item #1Cert #22347558 Grade NEAR MINT 7 Description 1958 Topps 310 Ernie Banks TypeCard
Line #5Item #1Cert #23613502 Grade NEAR MINT 7 Description 1971 Topps 5 Thurman Munson All-Star Rookie TypeCard
Line #6Item #1Cert #18660791 Grade NEAR MINT-MINT 8 Description 1971 Topps 341 Steve Garvey TypeCard
Line #7Item #1Cert #22796140 Grade NEAR MINT-MINT 8 Description 1975 Topps Mini 660 Hank Aaron TypeCard
Line #8Item #1Cert #01199793 Grade NEAR MINT-MINT 8 Description 1975 Topps Mini 228 George Brett TypeCard
Line #9Item #1Cert #15824754 Grade NEAR MINT-MINT 8 Description 1975 Topps 228 George Brett TypeCard
Line #10Item #1Cert #22667771 Grade NEAR MINT-MINT 8 Description 1976 Topps 19 George Brett TypeCard
Line #11Item #1Cert #06497777 Grade NEAR MINT-MINT 8 Description 1976 Topps 19 George Brett TypeCard
Line #12Item #1Cert #21618601 Grade NEAR MINT-MINT 8 Description 1976 Topps 19 George Brett TypeCard
Line #13Item #1Cert #22172242 Grade NEAR MINT-MINT 8 Description 1979 Topps 390 Earl Campbell TypeCard
Line #14Item #1Cert #22833794 Grade NEAR MINT-MINT 8 Description 1974 Topps 456 Dave Winfield TypeCard
Line #15Item #1Cert #90227670 Grade NEAR MINT-MINT 8 Description 1969 Topps 597 A.L. Rookies Floyd/Burchart/Fingers TypeCard
Comments
I like your strategy of reviewing the 1976 Topps George Brett's. Very low probability but with the payoff being so huge it is a great risk reward submission.
I would imagine the bump paid for the sub. True?
Thanks Dpeck.
Sub only cost me shipping plus membership so it worked well.
Have to look at prior closed sales for the Stengel but pop shows 42 so thinking it may be $500-750 card.
Nice!
I wouldn't mind seeing scans of all the Brett cards.
Will post the Casey and Brett's once mail arrives.
Does anyone know if PSA logs the cert numbers so they can tell when a card comes back for a second review? Or thurs, fourth, etc. Just wondering whether a re-re-review ever works.
Thx
Count on it.
Dave
Crack open the slab and send it back if you want it re-graded.
I actively collect Kirby Puckett. I have collections of Michael Jordan, Emmitt Smith, Roberto Clemente, Dwight Gooden, Tom Seaver, Errict Rhett and Evan Longoria.
Updated with scans of the Stengel and the Brett's. Really hoped to get 1 .5 bump on a Brett but no such luck. They are all very solid 8s.
The top left corner of Stengel looks touched/dinged, not 9 quality IMO
Nice Brett cards!
I don't see any ding on that corner. I think what you are seeing is a reflection of the light.
Collecting 1970s Topps baseball wax, rack and cello packs, as well as PCGS graded Half Cents, Large Cents, Two Cent pieces and Three Cent Silver pieces.
I agree with Tim.
Really nice.
From what I remember the 76T Brett is a tough one.
I like the Casey - I have a small lot that I picked up over 20 years ago - no stars and definitely no 9s!
Don't you wish PSA would send back their observations as part of the review fee for cards that don't receive upgrades. I think it would help rationalize the fees charged, making it a win/win.
Last month I received a card back with a post-it on the back that gave me an explanation, and was delighted so that at least I understood their observations.
Hopefully someone here reads this and runs with the idea.
Love that idea. Very cool to get a stickey with feedback.
BTW - my Stangel only has glare on top left not a touched corner.
I'm dissapponted that none of the Brett's got a bump. They are all solid 8s and of 8.5 is biased towards strong centering, at least 1 of the 3 should qualify.
Steve