WTB : 2.5 or 5 Indian

erickso1

Looking to pick up a 2.5 or 5 Indian. Looking to get it as close to melt as possible. Cleaned is okay, but needs to have a decent look to it. Shoot me price and photos and I'll respond back. Not sure what is out there.

erickso1

Got a couple responses. Let me know if you have anything that works.

jwitten

I have a lot of $2 1/2 coins, but letting go of one for close to melt would be losing money. What is your bottom price, and I will see if I have one in that range.

Chadc13

Check eBay liberty coins had $5 graded 61 for 345 with current eBay bucks discount.

MAN2004

That is an unbelievable price for a slabbed $5 MS61 Indian. They are $470-490 depending on quantity from APMEX. I recently paid almost that much for $2.5 AU55/58 Indians. I might beat you to that deal.

DancingFire

@Chadc13 said:
Check eBay liberty coins had $5 graded 61 for 345 with current eBay bucks discount.

PCGS MS61 $5 Inds? Link please?

DancingFire

@MAN2004 said:
That is an unbelievable price for a slabbed $5 MS61 Indian. They are $470-490 depending on quantity from APMEX. I recently paid almost that much for $2.5 AU55/58 Indians. I might beat you to that deal.

Not possible for $5 Inds! ..

FallGuy

@Chadc13 said:
Check eBay liberty coins had $5 graded 61 for 345 with current eBay bucks discount.

Unfortunately, that price is for $5 Libs only. The Indians are $100 more.

jwitten

I just picked up a nice $5 graded AU58 for $350, then got 8% bucks back on top of that. Seller gave me a deal, because they originally listed it as a $2 1/2, and I won it for under $260. They then refused the sale because of the error, but still gave me a decent deal of $350.

MAN2004

That's a good deal. I don't think you will see that deal again.