Took a chance...

coinlieutenant

Overall, I am happy. In my opinion PCGS netted this coin. The surfaces are better than most but still have been soap and watered in the past. Not a ton of luster on the coin, in fact it has nearly none. There is also a planchet issue at 1 oclock that I am perplexed by. Either way, this is a hard coin to find and may stay in the collection until the perfect XF comes my way.

John

ElmerFusterpuck

Not a bad looking coin at all, I think you did well. From a distance, it looks like a gold toned Capped Bust half!

coinlieutenant

For Topstuf

TPRC

I think I would have done nearly exactly what you did, and your analysis seemed spot on. From the more recent pic, I don't see how you can go wrong.