Future value discussion Mantle/Jordan

VintagemanEd

Just wondering what the thought is for value appreciation of a 52 Topps Mantle psa 3-4
Versus an 86 Jordan Psa 10. Which would you rather have to hold over the next 5-10 years?

addicted2ebay

I vote mantle

MrNearMint

I'm a Jordan collector but I'd go with mantle all day!

John Gibbons

Im assuming you are meaning sentimental value, correct?



Id have to go with Mantle.

DanBessette

Do you get any enjoyment out of the hobby?

Gemyanks10

Originally posted by: DanBessette
Do you get any enjoyment out of the hobby?

+ 1

charrigan

I'd personally opt for an index fund. My hobby money is for fun, not appreciation.

VintagemanEd

For those that gave an opinion on the two cards...... Thx..... Nice to hear

KendallCat

I would suggest a Mantle 3-4 nicely centered and a Jordan PSA 9 for $4k. Paying $20k+ for a 10 or getting a Mantle rookie and a 9 Jordan - would take the Mantle and the 9.

Dnice

Easily the Mantle.

ClockworkAngel

Definitely the Mantle

You might also want to consider a 1951Bowman Mantle. For the price range you're discussing, you can probably get a nice PSA 7. That's a card that has a lot more room for growth. The 52T Mantle has skyrocketed

Meatloaf

Mantle

bobmoat

I'd have to agree with Dr. Meatloaf.

UncleTwoPillow

HobbyistmanEd does.

nrm1977

Mantle all day!