ISA vs GMA

EagleEyeKid

Hypothetical question. Both have the one card you need in the exact same grade. Which would you take?
One guy grades stuff but sends all his stuff to PSA. Other guy grades stuff from his house while watching Gilligan's Island.

Grimster

Im confused as to what you are asking. Are you saying there is a card that has been graded by ISA and GMA....and both are the same grade....and you want to know which to buy?

I would take neither because I've never heard of either of those grading companies. lol

charrigan

Gotta go ISA, imo. Their grades at least sometimes come kind of close to right.

72skywalker

If he was watching the Gilligan's Island episode where the headhunters try to marry Ginger I would take ISA. If it was the movie of them escaping Gilligan's Island where Gilligan goes out to look for Mrs. Howell's dog before the storm I would go for GMA.

72skywalker

Brings us to the next important question? Ginger or Maryann?

I prefer Ginger myself

addicted2ebay

GMA.... There #4 in my book.

EagleEyeKid

I prefer Mary Ann .

Ok, the Skipper or Gilligan?

lawnmowerman

I'm torn. Ginger was a red head with nice white skin. Both of those qualities are A+. On the downside Ginger came off as a bit trashy. While I will admit, I do like my women a little on the trashy side but if it's too much then it's a turn off.

Now Maryann has the girl next door look, classic Americana. Brunette, pig tails, pretty face and sweet persona.

For me to pick a winner, I think what it would have to come down to is which one could make me the best sandwich.

olb31

i think ksa is ok, but there is usually a reason the card isn't in a beckett or psa holder.

StamkosFan

GMA.... There #4 in my book.

Interesting.

FootballCrazy

<< <i>If he was watching the Gilligan's Island episode where the headhunters try to marry Ginger I would take ISA. If it was the movie of them escaping Gilligan's Island where Gilligan goes out to look for Mrs. Howell's dog before the storm I would go for GMA. >>



If I am not mistaken, wasn't one of the headhunters played by former NFL star quarterback Roman Gabriel?

hyperchipper09

Find a raw card

craig44

Honestly, you should just wait for one from one of the big three graders