What do you think my Orr rookie will grade?

dgordo

LarkinCollector

Somewhere in the 5-6 range unless there's a surface issue that's not apparent in the scan. What grade is on it currently?

charrigan

4.

Some cards are ambiguous. This one, I can't see landing in any other grade.

It'll look better in a PSA holder and out of those BVG monstrosities

dgordo

<< <i>Somewhere in the 5-6 range unless there's a surface issue that's not apparent in the scan. What grade is on it currently? >>



Thanks, BVG 5.5

dgordo

<< <i>4.

Some cards are ambiguous. This one, I can't see landing in any other grade.

It'll look better in a PSA holder and out of those BVG monstrosities >>



If it ends up a 4 ill lose a few dollars but i agree it will look better.

vintagefun

Maybe a crossover with min grade 4.5 and you get lucky.

Nice card either way.

charrigan

Is it at PSA now or is the card something you're considering cracking/crossing over?

dgordo

<< <i>Is it at PSA now or is the card something you're considering cracking/crossing over? >>



Haven't sent yet, i will definitely send to psa eventually.

mlbfan2

4 orr higher.

See what I did there?

dgordo

<< <i>4 orr higher.

See what I did there? >>

uniship

4 all day every day

Dnice

You got a nice 4 right there.

80sOPC

Not be a downer but the cards looks miscut to me. I would say 5 MC, or a 3 without any qualifiers.