Earned a 70% grade at the Bean Bazaar today {;>)

coindeuce

Only disappointment was #10

1. 1858-O Dime Liberty Seated, Drapery [SDM1858O] PCGSAU53 30801970 Passed
2. 1871-S Dime Liberty Seated, Legend [SDM1871S] PCGSEF40 26229100 Not CAC
3. 1875 Dime Liberty Seated, Legend [SDM1875] PCGS MS64 14018374 Passed
4. 1876-CC Dime Liberty Seated, Legend [SDM1876CC] PCGS MS63 20392702 Passed
5. 1878-CC Dime Liberty Seated, Legend [SDM1878CC] PCGS VF30 26800725 Passed
6. 1880 Dime Liberty Seated, Legend [SDM1880] PCGS EF40 24057523 Not CAC
7. 1858-O Quarter Liberty Seated, No Motto [SQU1858O] PCGS AU53 30801977 Passed
8. 1840 Half Dollars Liberty Seated, NM Rev 1839 [LHM1840SL]PCGSVF30 29211897 Passed
9. 1864-S Half Dollars Liberty Seated, No Motto [LHM1864S]PCGSXF45 30935478 Passed
10. 1869 Dollars Liberty Seated, With Motto [L$M1869] PCGS EF40 22106026 Not CAC

AUandAG

From what I see on your submission I would not send them any more EF40 coins....


bob

steveben

those are pretty decent results. post a pic of the disappointment.

coindeuce

<< <i>those are pretty decent results. post a pic of the disappointment. >>



It was purchased from a forum member, and I am very pleased with the coin. It may have been just a tad too dark for JA to give it a pass.

crypto79

<< <i>

<< <i>those are pretty decent results. post a pic of the disappointment. >>



It was purchased from a forum member, and I am very pleased with the coin. It may have been just a tad too dark for JA to give it a pass.


>>



Wow that is pretty nice, considering the avg low quality (compared to my preferences) of stickered circulated seated stuff I am shocked at that dollar. Maybe something removed that I am missing instead of the look?

Billet7

Maybe the marks on the left by the hand, look like little chatter marks.

Flatwoods

I agree, looks better than most. It would be nice to know why it didn't sticker.

coinbuf

<< <i>I agree, looks better than most. It would be nice to know why it didn't sticker. >>



If you just got your results today you can call and ask John why it failed, he is very good about that.

crypto79

<< <i>

<< <i>I agree, looks better than most. It would be nice to know why it didn't sticker. >>



If you just got your results today you can call and ask John why it failed, he is very good about that. >>



95% of the time he will just say it is the under grade. If that is the case with this coin, hummmmmm.

stealer

<< <i>

<< <i>

<< <i>I agree, looks better than most. It would be nice to know why it didn't sticker. >>



If you just got your results today you can call and ask John why it failed, he is very good about that. >>



95% of the time he will just say it is the under grade. If that is the case with this coin, hummmmmm. >>


Based on the images I would say the soap clean is probably harsher-looking in hand.

Barndog

I take it you screen the coins before sending in (rather than just send everything you have on hand)?

amwldcoin

From the pictures of the 69 dollar I would say the surfaces are not quite there....but still a nice coin and I have seen worse in other series CAC!

coindeuce

<< <i>I take it you screen the coins before sending in (rather than just send everything you have on hand)? >>



I do screen them while keeping the CAC mission in mind. I thought that the dollar was very solid for the TPG grade in all criteria except the luster, which I may have overlooked. If there is no notation on the holder when it arrives, I'll call and ask if JA had made any notes about it.

winky

I love seated dollars. Maybe i could trade my entire Roosie collection for one.

Barndog

<< <i>

<< <i>I take it you screen the coins before sending in (rather than just send everything you have on hand)? >>



I do screen them while keeping the CAC mission in mind. I thought that the dollar was very solid for the TPG grade in all criteria except the luster, which I may have overlooked. If there is no notation on the holder when it arrives, I'll call and ask if JA had made any notes about it. >>



I screen too and try to learn a bit from past successes and failures. I do know photos can be deceiving, as I have some "lock CAC" coins if one judges by various images that I would never send to CAC because they'd be a waste of everyone's time.

Vbowling299

Not too Shabby

roadrunner

I like the preference to 1858-0 silver coinage.

topstuf

<< <i>I agree, looks better than most. It would be nice to know why it didn't sticker. >>



Maybe because it looks better than most.

oh, unload that gun!

coindeuce

<< <i>

<< <i>I agree, looks better than most. It would be nice to know why it didn't sticker. >>



Maybe because it looks better than most.

oh, unload that gun! >>



Hey buddy, the 1796 SE Dollar is next in the queue for a trip to Far Hills.

C0inCollect0r

Pretty good results overall. Congrats!