liberty peace dollar real or fake?

MrZ

Hi guys...i need help to identify two liberty peace dollar/1921-1922/which I recently discovered..because the finish on the coins..is it reproductions?I'm suspicious..and also a beginner. thanks
liberty

lasvegasteddy

image didn't post...try this...tinypic.com
welcome to tha club

MrZ

Thanks..i try that

StrikeOutXXX

Here you go:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/mutnj1bwximas9f/image.jpg?dl=0

MrZ

Thanks..it takes me time to figure it out

jmski52

Photos not clear enough to know for sure, but the 1921 looks like High Relief and I don't see anything suspicious about the 1922.

lasvegasteddy

the 1922 looks like it's in an ngc holder...go with what the holder says

the 1921
way to small an image to tell much from

MrZ

Unfortunately i have no clue yet how to upload higher resolution images here..but thankyou anyway ,..i don't want to burn to buying them

MrZ

c

lasvegasteddy

better images there

both are what we call problem coins here
the 22' isn't worth much more then "melt"

the 21
looks cleaned and polished...huge deduction in value for that

are you considering buying these?
if so
pass...save your money

MrZ

coindeuce

The 1921 looks genuine and lower end of the circulated spectrum - Very Good to Fine.
The 1922 is not encapsulated, rather just mounted in the insert from a late generation NGC holder, and quite frankly looks to be damaged by corrosion.

MrZ

You think they do not worth much? Than im going to pass on it

PerryHall

I like the 1921. The 1922 is not as attractive with that spotted toning---hopefully it looks better in hand.

CuKevin

<< <i>You think they do not worth much? Than im going to pass on it >>



1922 definitely has some problems. 1921 is in a low enough grade it isn't worth much either.

MrZ

to me looks like mold..kinda

ajaan

<< <i>1921 is in a low enough grade it isn't worth much either. >>


A 1921 Peace Dollar in VG isn't worth much? Since when? I thought it was a $60+ coin.

StrikeOutXXX

<< <i>

<< <i>1921 is in a low enough grade it isn't worth much either. >>


A 1921 Peace Dollar in VG isn't worth much? Since when? I thought it was a $60+ coin. >>



Don't feel bad, that comment had me searching because I thought I missed the memo too.

The last 2 certified ones on eBay went for (NGC VG10 - $71.24) and (PCGS VG10 - $110)
Seems the raw ones are anywhere from $50-$80.

MrZ

Thankyou guys ..I'm gona start my coin collection with something else than

lcoopie

spend some time on the boards before you buy anything

welcome

winky

Spend a little more, get a real silver dollar. I would pass on these, they look fake-ish.

LindeDad

Agree especially the 1921, and the 1922 looks like it been in the ground.

Note how thick the 1's are on the obverse as one tell.

gonzer

<< <i>I like the 1921. The 1922 is not as attractive with that spotted toning---hopefully it looks better in hand. >>



I like it too, it has charisma.

kaz

Welcome to the forum! I think posting the coins here before buying them was smart.