Going very big on first item sold 37,000.00 really?

JBrules

Nothing like going really big on your first item being sold on Ebay!!! Wow. Seller has a small history of buying but this is his first time selling. Some nice cards in this collection. Scam maybe or do you think it is legit?

37,000 dollar link

JBrules

Has anyone seen this listing?

addicted2ebay

It looks legit to me although the starting bid is too high IMO.

Dboneesq

Pretty crappy photos (and NO reverse scans) for such a high priced item.

charrigan

It looks legitimate to me, but a novice seller. Is this a good price for the items?

vintageinvestments

$22k

bounce

<< <i>$22k >>


Be serious - $22k isn't even close.

There are dozens of people who would take this lot at $22k if offered, I'll be the first in line for this lot at that price.

Estimates on the big boys:
1933 goudey PSA 4 Ruth's - $3,000-3,500 each
1933 goudey Gehrig 4 - $1,500-1,800
1934 goudey PSA 5 gehrig's - $3,000-3,500 each
1951 bowman mantle 6 - $6,000, probably more?
1952 bowman mantle 7 - $2,500-3,000

That's $22k using the low end, and there's still these to go:
1953 mantle psa 6 - $1,500-2,000
1956 mantle psa 7 - 1,500-2,000
1939 dimaggio psa 6 - $1,000-1,500
1941 dimaggio psa 4 - $800+
maris auto
mantle auto
That's easily another $5-6k LOW END.

Just for arguments sake, let's say my LOW END is still 25% too high, you'd still come out at over $22k for the lot.

I agree $37k is a bit high, but it's not crazy high.

Dialj

Not to mention the '33 Delong Gehrig.