XY Details Cleaning Genuine - In general Yes or no ?What do you think? I said yes to graffiti and ri

CMCART

XY Details Cleaning Genuine - In general Yes or no ? What do you think? I said yes to graffiti and rim damage and no to Cleaning

bsshog40

Really hard to tell by the pics. I'm presuming maybe dipped out.

braddick

1886 = water/baking soda cleaned a couple of decades ago...

CMCART

I'm talking in general about buying cleaning coins - not about my 2 coins here

LindeDad

What if they went threw the laundry back in the days of homemade lye soap?
Ma considered them tips back then.

johnny9434

What if they went threw the laundry back in the days of homemade lye soap?
Ma considered them tips back then.

clean is clean and that was clean

Baley

Impossible for me to answer yes or no to any specific coin without price information and context within a given collection.

at "reasonable market" prices, they'd be a no for me, but then again, so would any Morgan, haven't bought a Morgan in 10 years or more

for some collectors these might be wonderful additions to their sets at the right price, and bend my arm behind my back I'd probably bid somewhere around Good prices for them

Baley

I said yes to graffiti and rim damage and no to Cleaning

If you said yes to rim damage then you also said yes to cleaning with the 1886; they only listed the worst problem on the holder.

braddick

Remember when the older ANACS (small white slabs) would list just about every problem on the insert?
Sometimes there would barely be room to list them all!
(Jeremy had a cool bust dime with a litany of problems listed.)