GRADES ADDED IN FIRST POST - a small group of PCGS & NGC Bust Halves

Yonico

I've sent a group of coins to Bob Campbell (aka Robec) for imaging, and I'm extremely happy with the results! thank you Bob!

care to guess the grades? variety? comments and opinions on the coins are all welcome.

thanks for looking!

Yoni

* here are the grades*

1808 - NGC XF45

1821 - PCGS XF45

1824 - PCGS AU50

1829 - PCGS AU53

1833 - PCGS AU50

1835 - NGC VF30





COIN #1 - 1808 50C (NGC)















COIN #2 - 1821 50C (PCGS)














COIN #3 - 1824 50C (PCGS)















COIN #4 - 1829 50C (PCGS)















COIN #5 - 1833 50C (PCGS) [1st SET OF PICS IS BY BRANDON (BRG5658), 2nd SET BY BOB]
































COIN #6 - 1835 50C (NGC)

grip

just for grins

xf 45
au 55
xf40
xf45
au 58
au 55
vf 30

Yonico

<< <i>just for grins

xf 45
au 55
xf40
xf45
au 58
au 55
vf 30 >>



2/7 !

2/6 really, as you guessed twice on the 33'.

very nice!

grip

Well that wasn't good ...but still fun

BustHalfBrian

40
50
45
53 (edit to add: maybe AU-Det, cleaned)
53
30

Yonico

<< <i>40
50
45
53 (edit to add: maybe AU-Det, cleaned)
53
30 >>



also 2/6!

keep the guesses coming!

kaz

OK here are my WAGs as what the assigned grades were:

1808-EF40
1821-AU53
1824-AU50
1829-AU53
1833-AU50
1835-EF45

a nice looking group of busties!

Yonico

<< <i>OK here are my WAGs as what the assigned grades were:

1808-EF40
1821-AU53
1824-AU50
1829-AU53
1833-AU50
1835-EF45

a nice looking group of busties! >>



3/6 correct!

will add the grades tonight

mozin

35
45
45
40
50
30

jayPem

these are all interesting for sure, although some of them look like they could details grade for either questionable color or old cleaning..
but I will asume they are all in prob free holders and play along accordingly

25
45
35
53
45
15

indeetlib

40
50
53
55
50
45

Sweet coins!

Yonico

Mozin - 3/6. Nice!

Jaypem - 2/6. Yes, these are all in problem-free holders.

Indeetlib - only 1/6 correct , but you were closest to MY grade opinions on most of them

jayPem

How can Mozin and Kaz BOTH have 3/6 correct...?

Yonico

<< <i>How can Mozin and Kaz BOTH have 3/6 correct...? >>



3/6 meaning they guessed 3 right out of the 6..
They don't have to be guessing the SAME coins right, they just both got 3 right and 3 wrong

jayPem

Oh...

jughead1893

25
50
35
45
40
20

Yonico

Sorry FadeToBlack, Jughead1893 - 0/6 !

Grades now added in the first post.

Thanks everyone for your guesses!

Yonico

<< <i>I'll stick to the Morgans, then. >>



Hahaha

Nah.. I admit that most of these were a little tricky..


See, here and on the forums ATS, for the

1808, guesses ranged from VF25 to XF45

1824, from VF35 to AU53

1833, VF30 to AU58!

And on the 1835, F15 to XF45!!

BustHalfBrian

<< <i>How can Mozin and Kaz BOTH have 3/6 correct...? >>



Because some are NGC grades

Yonico

<< <i>

<< <i>How can Mozin and Kaz BOTH have 3/6 correct...? >>



Because some are NGC grades >>



funny you should say that - you did better guessing the NGC-graded coins than you did with the PCGS ones!

jayPem

These were a bit tricky...which makes for a great GTG thread.
The combo of late die states and secondary toning is a situation where net grades thrive !

The large pics are really cool for seeing all the detail on these coins, but I'll bet the eye appeal on these in hand and normal sized would help their cause
in the grading room

kaz

I was way off on the 1835. I think I got confused as to strike vs wear and the luster I could see around the devices made me lean towards XF. Anyway that was fun and made me think a bit too which is never a bad thing (unless you ask my wife!)

Treashunt

Nice Busties