Your Opinion (PSA 8 '75 Brett RC)

Mintacular

Got this card back, am happy with the grade. Do you think it is a low, average, or above average "8". Bought it from a raw set and subbed. Thanks, Pat The back is nice one tiny black tar mark the size of pinhead. (Note: The little "scuff" mark between the stems of the "A" is a mark on the scanner, not on actual card, same with light white stain left border which is from scanner).

Counselor

Would be above average, if not for fish eyes. Nice card

Dnice

The card looks like it could have also been an 8.5. I've seen plenty 8.5's with fish eyes. These unfortunately are pretty big and noticeable and I think that they take away from the cards overall beauty which is why they deemed an an 8.

Dboneesq

<< <i>Would be above average, if not for fish eyes. Nice card >>


I agree, but to me (and this differs with each person) fish eyes have a negative effect on the way a card looks. I would have to say its a low end 8.

Mintacular

Yeah, I wish the fisheyes weren't there but I would say they look better in "Royals" than on the bold borders....

Bosox1976

Centering 9
Corners 8.5
Edges 8.5
Surface 7.5 (Those fisheyes are more distracting than "average" fisheyes)

Super nice 8. Here is my 8.5 for comparison:

grote15

The fisheyes don't bother me nearly as much as centering would or other condition defects, especially when they are hidden in the backdrop of the team name. I would personally consider it a higher grade 8 with that centering and those sharp corners. Regisatration is also realy nice.

RookieHOFers

Pat, with that centering, that card is above average to me. Its nice.