Edward Cogan 1870 inquiry...

Broadstruck

Does anyone know if Edward Cogan had more then one auction in May of 1870

Sonorandesertrat

The Adams reference only lists the John Allan Sale.

Broadstruck

<< <i>The Adams reference only lists the John Allan Sale. >>



Thanks that's what I figured... Can't seem to locate what was supposed to have sold in this sale.

I've gone through the whole catalog beginning to end and end to beginning just in case it was wrongly categorized.

Bummer!

DeliaBug

If it is May you're after, May 1870 was also E. L. Mason's sale of Montroville Wilson Dickeson. Pretty thin at 15 pages and 422 lots.

If it's Allan you're after he had a consignment in May, 1864 w/Bangs Merwin. Also thin at 16 pages & 416 lots.

If it's something else, let me know and I can take a look.

Broadstruck

Thanks but it's definitely a Edward Cogan sale and was supposed to be lot 65.

Looking for one of William C. Prime's consignments which was to have been plated.

Unfortunately if 1870 is a typo Prime consigned with Cogan regularly over a 20 year span.

DeliaBug

Only six Cogan sales were plated so that should narrow it down for you. I also have copies of them all if you want something checked.

Edit to add:

Here are the six lot #65's for his plated sales.
MACKENZIE - Roman Denarii
ALLAN - Septimius Severus
MONTREAL - Roman Thurium
CAUFMANN - 1806 Half, Fair
SANFORD - 1862 Pattern Dollar. (Which doesn't exist so who knows what he meant. His description on this is 1862 Do. do. without do. do.)
COHEN - Ancient. Nero / Rev Africa
JENKS - 1840 Dollar

Hope that helps, but it doesn't look too good.