Question about getting a PSA graded rookie autographed.

BobTheHammer

Hey all,

I have a hypothetical question. Suppose I had a PSA 10 Montana rookie that I wanted to get signed at a show.
If PSA was at the show, could I have them remove the card from the slab, watch Montana sign it, and have it reslabbed.

Naturally it would be suicide to crack out a PSA 10 Montana rookie, have it signed, and resubmit hoping for another 10 grade.

Any way this would be possible to assure it stays a PSA 10?

Opinions appreciated.

Dboneesq

<< <i>Any way this would be possible to assure it stays a PSA 10? >>


I'm not sure, but I think once the card is cracked out, all bets are off. The card would be regraded in the as is condition.

ANYWAY, IMO it would be CRAZY to crack open a PSA 10 Rookie worth that much! Go buy a nice looking PSA 7 for $50.00 and get that one autographed!

BobTheHammer

<< <i>

<< <i>Any way this would be possible to assure it stays a PSA 10? >>


I'm not sure, but I think once the card is cracked out, all bets are off. The card would be regraded in the as is condition.

ANYWAY, IMO it would be CRAZY to crack open a PSA 10 Rookie worth that much! Go buy a nice looking PSA 7 for $50.00 and get that one autographed! >>



Agreed, kinda going for the only PSA 10 Montana auto rookie deal. If there is no way to assure the grade would remain, I would never do it.

SDSportsFan

Have the player sign the slab.

Steve

charrigan

They would regrade after it's cracked.

LarkinCollector

<< <i>Have the player sign the slab.

Steve >>


Then send it in for a massive blue flip that slabs the slab.

bounce

DO NOT crack out a 10 to get signed - go find a nice 7 or 8 and have that signed