Would you rather own a high pop PSA 10 rookie of your favorite player, or a POP 1 psa 10 non-rookie

edmundfitzgerald

I'd rather own the tougher, low pop non-rookie myself, as long as the card was really known as a tough one, almost in white whale neighborhood.

LarkinCollector

<< <i>I'd rather own the tougher, low pop non-rookie myself, as long as the card was really known as a tough one, almost in white whale neighborhood. >>


Agreed, with Larkin it's way too easy to get 10s on the big 3 rookies. Actually, I'd take a PSA7 of quite a few of his tough cards to even find at all over 10s of his rookie.

cree

I very much enjoy collecting PSA 10 Rookies but there is something special about hunting down the really Rare and obscure cards in any grade.