Grade these 1961 Topps Aaron and McCovey

Csmontie

Let me know your thoughts Thanks





]

slum22

There are far better experts on the boards here, but my opinion would be somewhere in the 6 to 7 range on both. Leaning more towards 6's. Good luck and post results so we know how you do.

Dpeck100

I would guess in the 5 range on both. You might get a 5.5 on the Aaron because the centering is strong.

What grades are you expecting?

SidePocket

6 and 5 I think.

heritage

Aaron 6 McCovey a 5 still nice cards.

1954

I think PSA 4 on both. Very nice cards though

bobbyw8469

I'm thinking 5 on both.

orioles93

Aaron is PSA 4-5 to me. Too soft of corners and too many print dots for a 6.
Mccovey i say is PSA 5.

Csmontie

thanks everyone I was hoping for PSA 6s, but it looks like mor ein the 4 to 5 range.
Again thanks for your opinions

bobsbbcards

6's on both. Here's an Aaron 6 currently on the Bay. Yours matches up nicely.

Stingray

<< <i>I think PSA 4 on both. Very nice cards though >>



+1

GrandMasterB

The Aaron looks either trimmed or mis-cut. The McCovey is likely a 4.5 because of the surface.

RyanAdmirer

<< <i>I'm thinking 5 on both. >>



Ditto

MrNearMint

Wow, I was thinking 7 for Aaron and 5-6 for mccovey.

gemint

<< <i>The Aaron looks either trimmed or mis-cut. >>



+1

Csmontie

Grandmaster and Gemint .... I dont think it is trimmed or mis-cut.
It matches well up against the other 61s I have. Why do you say that it looks trimmed or miscut?

gemint

<< <i>Grandmaster and Gemint .... I dont think it is trimmed or mis-cut.
It matches well up against the other 61s I have. Why do you say that it looks trimmed or miscut? >>



The left edge on the front looks wavy. On the back, the right edge flairs out near the middle cartoon. This is typical of factory miscuts. On the back, there is a scuff mark near the card number and the edge looks like it tapers inward. Might be artifacts of the scan but that's always the challenge of grading based on scans.