Manning...

MrNearMint

STILL THE GREATEST!!!

OAKESY25

+ 1

Meatloaf

he is great, not the "greatest." There are 5 people in front of him in that line...many who played in an era where the D was tougher due to wide open rules....relax on the greatest. Joe Montana never failed in a Superbowl....and certainly would not check into a 3rd and long draw play in the third quarter down 25+ pts!

3BoyzTrading

He has been great for a lomg time but so have many others....there will always be an argument on who the best is....as much as I like Manning...well I am a Niner fan...and thos 80s teams were great!