Home› Trading Cards & Memorabilia Forum
Options

Shipping charge question...

I don't really like posting about these things, but need some help on this one. I'm doing a show in December and bought a ton of auto's/GU stuff from a guy that was priced at .50 a piece. They were $2.50 for the first item and .50 after that. The guy's charging excessive shipping on this stuff. I'm paying more in shipping than what I paid for the purchase. He's not willing to come down to a reasonable price. $18.50 is a bit excessive for 33 cards...right?

Comments

  • Options
    PMKAYPMKAY Posts: 1,372 ✭✭
    It is but if he stated that ahead of time you should have known what type of shipping charge you were going to get.
  • Options
    I paid what was due. I did ask for a better price break and he refused. Definitely not shopping with this guy again. He is totally making money off of shipping.
  • Options
    otwcardsotwcards Posts: 5,291 ✭✭✭
    Whether he is making money or not, his terms were stated. If you had asked about a discount PRIOR to purchasing, then you would've had a better idea of what you were getting into. To be upset because the seller did not deviate from his stated policy is understandable, but if anyone is in the wrong, it is you for possibly assuming that he'd work something out in your favor. Had he listed the cards for $1.00 each and a total of $2.50 s/h for the entire order, would you have purchased the cards? If so, you're $0.50 ahead of the game...
  • Options
    dennis07dennis07 Posts: 1,842 ✭✭✭
    I pass on a lot of stuff because I don't like someone's shipping charges. I have been known to e-mail sellers to let them know their stuff would fit into a small or a medium
    flat rate box and they could send the stuff for a lot less than what they charge. I try to do it in a professional way.
    33 cards would fit into a small flat rate box and the cost is about $5.15. Just mark this one down as a cheap lesson learned.
    Collecting 1970 Topps baseball
  • Options
    I did communicate with him before I bid. He told me he would give me fair market shipping cost. If anything, I learned a lesson and he lost a return buyer. As a seller my policy is that if I'm going to charge more it's going to be in the cost of the card, not the shipping. Today you can ship just about anything (small lot size) for under $10.
    These things better come in top loaders, penny sleeves, and be packed well.
  • Options
    CDsNutsCDsNuts Posts: 10,092 ✭
    You bought the cards for .50 each, he's not exactly making a killing. In the end you're paying $1 a card which is about the going rate for common autos/relics. Instead of looking just at his shipping charges, look at the whole package- what are you getting and what are you paying gross?

    If he were to ask $1 each with free shipping you probably wouldn't have bought most/all of them, so in the end he's making a good business decision.
  • Options
    itzagoneritzagoner Posts: 8,753 ✭✭


    << <i>If anything, I learned a lesson and he lost a return buyer. >>



    if you make money off this purchase and don't return to buy again, the lesson hasn't been learned.

    what Lee said. if the package deal pays off, why not deal again under the same terms?
  • Options


    << <i>You bought the cards for .50 each, he's not exactly making a killing. In the end you're paying $1 a card which is about the going rate for common autos/relics. Instead of looking just at his shipping charges, look at the whole package- what are you getting and what are you paying gross?

    If he were to ask $1 each with free shipping you probably wouldn't have bought most/all of them, so in the end he's making a good business decision. >>



    You're right man. I need to eat a snickers and stop whining.
  • Options
    otwcardsotwcards Posts: 5,291 ✭✭✭
    It never ceases to amaze me how many people get hung up on shipping prices. The bottom line is simply the bottom line which is the NET cost to ME. If I am ready, willing and able to spend $1000 on an item, should it make a difference whether it is $800 with $200 shipping or $1000 with free shipping? If the money is going in the seller's pockets, should I really be worried how much goes into any given pocket as long as what I'm paying in total is fair and equitable?

    If I ask a specific question and get a vague answer, then I'm either going to ask for a specific answer to the question or assume the very worst.

    I've learned over the years that if you expect the worst, you will never be disappointed...
  • Options
    DboneesqDboneesq Posts: 18,222 ✭✭


    << <i>

    << <i>You bought the cards for .50 each, he's not exactly making a killing. In the end you're paying $1 a card which is about the going rate for common autos/relics. Instead of looking just at his shipping charges, look at the whole package- what are you getting and what are you paying gross? If he were to ask $1 each with free shipping you probably wouldn't have bought most/all of them, so in the end he's making a good business decision. >>



    You're right man. I need to eat a snickers and stop whining. >>



    Here you go:image
    STAY HEALTHY!

    Doug

    Liquidating my collection for the 3rd and final time. Time for others to enjoy what I have enjoyed over the last several decades. Money could be put to better use.
  • Options
    LarkinCollectorLarkinCollector Posts: 8,975 ✭✭✭✭✭
    That's the most delicious looking Snickers I've ever seen.
  • Options
    fur72fur72 Posts: 2,348 ✭✭
    This is a tough call for both sides. On the sellers side I would hope he would make some type of concession on the shipping charges. But as a seller you need to take into consideration bubble mailers, penny sleeves, card savers 1's, ever empty . If someone reached out to me though I would try to make it right and sometimes do so as it doesn't cost me anything extra to ship one or 3 raw cards. The key for sellers is to price their cards accordingly so they get the return they want.
  • Options
    miwlvrnmiwlvrn Posts: 4,337 ✭✭✭✭✭
    All the replies on this thread are pretty much spot on, good job everyone. I do want to add some advice that you take caution when leaving DSR's. A couple/few years ago I won a lot of single-card auctions from a seller, probably a little less than 50 of them or so. In this situation, the seller did not offer a combined item shipping discount. Nonetheless, the total price w/ shipping included was still good enough for me not to be upset about it. I left positive feedback for each item and did not discuss the shipping within the text of the feedback either. However, I left him 2's for his S/H DSR (all 5's' on the other 3 categories) since the actual shipping cost as printed on the label was many many many many many times lower than what I paid, and he didn't offer anything back on that. Well, since each transaction was an individual card rather than a near-50-card lot, it was a whole lot of DSR's left rather than just 1. ebay suspended my buying at that time for I think around 60 days because according to them since I sell as much as I buy, their trust & safety dept. claimed I was abusing the feedback system in order to sabatoge other sellers who sell cards too by manipulating the marketplace based on lowering their DSR's compared to mine, and with that one transaction but with separately listed items, I far exceeded the quantity of low DSR's permitted to be left by buyers in a year. Wish I could remember the exact phrasing they used in their allegations since it sounded a lot more ridiculously outlandish than my paraphrasing here, but it's been a long time since then now. That seller and I weren't selling the same items so there wasn't competition. That type of behavior w/ feedback wouldn't be strong enough to affect the market anyway. But most important to me, this was in no way my motivation for leaving a low shipping DSR whatsoever and I completely oppose ebay's thinking on that one. Either way, lesson learned for me. I still don't mind the purchase since the total money spent even with the shipping was appropriate for what I had in mind as value for the lot. My point in sharing this anecdote is that I don't advise leaving more than one low DSR even if you bought a bunch of things since it's not worth the ebay hassle. I doubt I've ever left a 1 or 2 in a DSR in any category since then, and it is one more item in a long list of reasons why I feel the feedback system on ebay is severely flawed since the rules prevent not only those who might abuse the system but also valuable honest/accurate feedback too.
  • Options
    All the replies on this thread are pretty much spot on, good job everyone. I do want to add some advice that you take caution when leaving DSR's. A couple/few years ago I won a lot of single-card auctions from a seller, probably a little less than 50 of them or so. In this situation, the seller did not offer a combined item shipping discount. Nonetheless, the total price w/ shipping included was still good enough for me not to be upset about it. I left positive feedback for each item and did not discuss the shipping within the text of the feedback either. However, I left him 2's for his S/H DSR (all 5's' on the other 3 categories) since the actual shipping cost as printed on the label was many many many many many times lower than what I paid, and he didn't offer anything back on that. Well, since each transaction was an individual card rather than a near-50-card lot, it was a whole lot of DSR's left rather than just 1. ebay suspended my buying at that time for I think around 60 days because according to them since I sell as much as I buy, their trust & safety dept. claimed I was abusing the feedback system in order to sabatoge other sellers who sell cards too by manipulating the marketplace based on lowering their DSR's compared to mine, and with that one transaction but with separately listed items, I far exceeded the quantity of low DSR's permitted to be left by buyers in a year. Wish I could remember the exact phrasing they used in their allegations since it sounded a lot more ridiculously outlandish than my paraphrasing here, but it's been a long time since then now. That seller and I weren't selling the same items so there wasn't competition. That type of behavior w/ feedback wouldn't be strong enough to affect the market anyway. But most important to me, this was in no way my motivation for leaving a low shipping DSR whatsoever and I completely oppose ebay's thinking on that one. Either way, lesson learned for me. I still don't mind the purchase since the total money spent even with the shipping was appropriate for what I had in mind as value for the lot. My point in sharing this anecdote is that I don't advise leaving more than one low DSR even if you bought a bunch of things since it's not worth the ebay hassle. I doubt I've ever left a 1 or 2 in a DSR in any category since then, and it is one more item in a long list of reasons why I feel the feedback system on ebay is severely flawed since the rules prevent not only those who might abuse the system but also valuable honest/accurate feedback too.


    When a seller gets above 2.00% of low ratings (1 or 2 stars) in any one category, ebay puts a hold on that sellers account for 30 days until the next evaluation. They won't be able to list any new items and for anything they sell paypal will put a few week hold on any funds coming in. It really sucks and is a huge inconvenience for anybody trying to grow an ebay business. So basically you could single-handedly stop a guy from listing on ebay for a month if you had an axe to grind. By leaving 50 low ratings, you most likely made that happen for your seller which is why it raised a red flag for ebay. I'm not saying you were right or wrong, I'm just letting you know the results of leaving so many low ratings for one guy.

    If you think about it it's kind of insane- all I need is for 3 people out of 100 to think my shipping fees are a little too high and I will lose my listing privileges for a month. But that's the system ebay has set up and we all have to deal with it.

    Lee
  • Options
    JoeBanzaiJoeBanzai Posts: 12,854 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Typical moronic ebay way of doing business. You are unhappy with a seller and leave the appropriate feedback and your account gets a "hold" put on it?

    Keep up the good work and PLEASE don't do anything about bid retractions either.

    image
    2013,14 and 15 Certificate Award Winner Harmon Killebrew Master Set and Master Topps Set
  • Options
    miwlvrnmiwlvrn Posts: 4,337 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>When a seller gets above 2.00% of low ratings (1 or 2 stars) in any one category, ebay puts a hold on that sellers account for 30 days until the next evaluation. They won't be able to list any new items and for anything they sell paypal will put a few week hold on any funds coming in. It really sucks and is a huge inconvenience for anybody trying to grow an ebay business. So basically you could single-handedly stop a guy from listing on ebay for a month if you had an axe to grind. By leaving 50 low ratings, you most likely made that happen for your seller which is why it raised a red flag for ebay. I'm not saying you were right or wrong, I'm just letting you know the results of leaving so many low ratings for one guy.

    If you think about it it's kind of insane- all I need is for 3 people out of 100 to think my shipping fees are a little too high and I will lose my listing privileges for a month. But that's the system ebay has set up and we all have to deal with it.

    Lee >>



    I hear you on the results, for sure. That instance occurred back when the DSR system was pretty new and I admittedly hadn't figured out that repercussion yet. I apologized as that obviously wasn't my intent and that seller and I were and still are on good terms. I wish the feedback could have lumped all items together as a lot rather than hit them individually. Like I said, lesson learned and all have moved on, though I suppose I see how other people out there who may actually choose to be malicious could try to stop a seller using DSR's (pointless p-ing in the ocean if you ask me though). Really what I wanted to do with sharing that story was warn others not to leave a whole bunch of low DSR's for a similar situation based on what I've described above. By the way, the seller did not lose his ability to sell in this case.

    I think a better solution than having a shipping DSR would be to consider developing an accurate/representative way to have the ebay programming automatically calculate a score for each seller's s/h. They already have the amount charged in your listing, and if you print the label off their system, they'll have the amount the seller spent on shipping too. You'd also have to factor in a certain reasonable assumed flat rate or percentage allowance for shipping supplies and a little time and effort of packaging it up, plus another allowance for ebay/paypal fees taken out of the shipping. I think if you were good about including everything that should be included, it wouldn't be that hard to write up some sort of program to give you an accurate shipping score and then take away the buyer's chance to grade you on shipping charges. I would then add a new DSR that let buyers score sellers on their packaging safety instead, which I personally would love to see when checking out a seller's info.

  • Options
    DoctorKDoctorK Posts: 868 ✭✭✭
    I view shipping costs like auction premium cost. Simply factor it in when making the purchase. No reason to get bent out of shape about it. If the total cost is too high--don't bid/purchase.
  • Options
    fiveninerfiveniner Posts: 4,111 ✭✭✭


    << <i>

    << <i>

    << <i>You bought the cards for .50 each, he's not exactly making a killing. In the end you're paying $1 a card which is about the going rate for common autos/relics. Instead of looking just at his shipping charges, look at the whole package- what are you getting and what are you paying gross? If he were to ask $1 each with free shipping you probably wouldn't have bought most/all of them, so in the end he's making a good business decision. >>



    You're right man. I need to eat a snickers and stop whining. >>



    Here you go:image >>



    STOP IT DOUG !!!!JUST STOP IT,Youre killing me!!!
    Tony(AN ANGEL WATCHES OVER ME)
  • Options
    I just can't believe this thread is still going.
Sign In or Register to comment.