I don't want to be a downer, but honestly, the Jones is the only one I would bother grading and hope for a 7-8. A nicer Hagen/Jones pair raw recently sold for just over $100 PWCC
I love the vintage golf, but Jones is really the only one that sells well. His 20's stuff has been hot recently. Hagen (probably a 6-6.5 with the top edge ding, soft top left corner) would sell for as much on a raw BIN/BO as you're likely to get for graded. Vardon might get a 9 (possible o/c qualifier, haven't measured if it falls in line), but there's little interest outside of a select few. None of the other names are recognizable to most and the Collett/Whitcombe have ST/PD qualifiers written all over them.
For some reason, Churchman's golf and boxing cards are relatively easy to find in high grade. PSA 4-7 are usually cheaper graded than equal raw examples. I would definitely sub the Jones and sell the rest raw.
Comments
I love the vintage golf, but Jones is really the only one that sells well. His 20's stuff has been hot recently. Hagen (probably a 6-6.5 with the top edge ding, soft top left corner) would sell for as much on a raw BIN/BO as you're likely to get for graded. Vardon might get a 9 (possible o/c qualifier, haven't measured if it falls in line), but there's little interest outside of a select few. None of the other names are recognizable to most and the Collett/Whitcombe have ST/PD qualifiers written all over them.
thanks for the comments