good deal?1873 OPEN 3 $2 1/2 GOLD QUARTER EAGLE PCGS GRADED MS 62

lostincoins

some of these have sold for over 700 on heritage so would this be considered a good deal?
linkknil

Placid

If something is a good deal and you post about it here, chances are good it will be gone soon.

kimber45ACP

lostincoins

thats why I posted it I don't want that right now I am tied up in some of my vintage horns right now and untill they sell i am a bit cash poor but if some one on the board wants it it is all good.

Unknown

This content has been removed.

roadrunner

Can't be that good of a deal if:

1. It's being sold by a guy named "estate lawyer"
2. 8 offers to buy it have been rejected already
3. Seller says it has to go and it's unreserved.......yet it's not an auction and has a Buy It Now price. ????????????
4. $595 sounds like plenty of me for an MS62 $2-1/2 even if a slightly better date. You can buy Philly type coins (1899-1908) of this denomination in MS64 for $630-$660.
The price is in line with other MS62ish type coins. These aren't anything special that I can see. NGC 62's sell for $450-$550. And in generic gold, I can't see paying a
premium for a holder.

lostincoins

just thought some here might like it with all the millionaires floating about. I looked at heritage an they were selling for as much as 700.00. Thats all, nice coin but not for me at this time. I just sold my 1911 2.50 Indian.

Durexmetals

Most recent auction is $483 stacks/bowers

Definitely a fair deal @595 for that slightly better date

If cac would put a sticker on it... I'm sure it we would be a great deal.

MsMorrisine

Would it CAC with that odd coloration on the reverse?

Durexmetals

Hard to tell from the pics if its coloration or shadow

lostincoins

Both of these sold at heritage for much more what makes them wort 700 to 900
link
link2

OnlyGoldIsMoney

<< <i>Would it CAC with that odd coloration on the reverse? >>




Agreed, coin does not look right. If CAC approved the $595 price is reasonable.