I sent this coin and it came back Genuine - Details (91 - Questionable Color)It's a 1824 half dollar

Type2

I sent it in for a customer and he got so mad that it came back Genuine - AU Details (91 - Questionable Color) he told me if i wanted to buy it i said yes and he said how about $200 bucks for it i said ok and paid him. I think it's a nice coin what do you think? should i crack it and try again? or just let it be.

Unknown

This content has been removed.

TwoSides2aCoin

... i think your customer was properly enraged and you suck.

edit for crappy spelling

silverpop

the color looks off and it will be called questionable color once again

lostincoins

Oh boy the color is way off you should be up set and not like the coin . So sell it to me for $100.00 lol did my jedi mind trick work?

BustHalfBrian

color looks a little hinky but I'm more concerned that it may have been cleaned.

PCGS made the right call, IMO

Pokermandude

Looks to be cleaned/retoned to me.

steveben

old cleaning maybe?

i would say try again, because you have less in it than he did (i assume)...why not try?

Walkerguy21D

The photos appear to show numerous hairlines on both sides.....color aside, I think it's likely to gennie for one reason or another.
But it's a decent raw coin for $200.

LindeDad

Reconsideration?

Type2

<< <i>Oh boy the color is way off you should be up set and not like the coin . So sell it to me for $100.00 lol did my jedi mind trick work? >>

Let me see nope not this time.

STONE

At least it's Genuine

SoCalBigMark

Send it across the street, you sell tires not coins, right?

coinsarefun

Is that a secure plus scan?

Type2

<< <i>Send it across the street, you sell tires not coins, right? >>

Ya Mark your right still round and i'll sell any thing Cars, Trucks, Loders, Scrap, House, Coins you name it no sham in my game it's all about profit and yes Stephanie it is a secure plus scan i'll take a pic of it next week my little girl went to camp and took my Camera with her so it will be a week with no photos.

keyman64

Crack it. Keep it in the gasket, lay it on the window sill of a steamy bathroom for a few months to let it crust over a tiny bit, flip it for over for an equal amount of time, send it back in to PCGS....ALL FIXED...although it would be a bit more crusty. My 50 cents on the matter. And yes, I have done this successfully before although it was with a Mercury Dime that came back cleaned.

coinsarefun

<< <i>Crack it. Keep it in the gasket, lay it on the window sill of a steamy bathroom for a few months to let it crust over a tiny bit, flip it for over for an equal amount of time, send it back in to PCGS....ALL FIXED...although it would be a bit more crusty. My 50 cents on the matter. And yes, I have done this successfully before although it was with a Mercury Dime that came back cleaned. >>







I agree to crack it out
Not sure about the bathroom though but I would just leave
it in a clean area and submit again.
Since it is a secure plus scan the color always looks off
If I interpret the secure plus right, the coin looks fine.

coinbuf

Looks like a coin that was cleaned/diped and has started a secondary toning process. I like the way these look but the services are not so keen on this look; unless you do as was suggested and add some crust it has little chance of grading imo.

Eddited to add: I have an 1830 with this same look and it has failed at both.

Type2

Here is a pic from my phone never did this befor i forget they do this now ..

EagleEye

Some coins are not ment to be submitted. This is one of them. Unless you want it in another "Genuine" holder, don't bother and enjoy it in your raw collection, or sell it.

poorguy

Heck, I think that is a darn pretty cbh. You did good for $200.