Thoughts on Cracking these???

hookem

I am considering cracking these and submitting them back to PSA. Let me know your thoughts if I am just wasting money...

Hoping for a 1.5 or 2. I can't stand a PSA 1 unless it has a pinhole.







I bought this raw on the board. Submitted to BVG and got a 5 then cracked and sent to PSA. I think it should be a 5 but I am biased.







Another raw purchase on the board that was submitted to PSA. I just want a number grade. Left edge is the concern but they have given grades to other similar cuts.

MrNearMint

I would probably leave them alone. I personally don't like having a bunch of money invested in submitting, cracking and re-submitting unless they would have high grade potential.

Bosox1976

If that's a rip on the Mays border, I think it will always be a 1.

hookem

<< <i>If that's a rip on the Mays border, I think it will always be a 1. >>



I always just thought it was a dented edge but I looked real close and it is a tear It does not break through to the back but it is a tear. Does that mean it is an auto 1 like a pinhole?

Bosox1976

I've never see higher than 1 for a tear. Hate to be the bearer of bad news...

Piggs

I believe these are graded correctly.

Dboneesq

<< <i>I believe these are graded correctly. >>


I have to agree and say leave them as is.

Big80s

In my opinion, you could swing a numerical grade on the Palmer, because of the set its from.

heritage

I would just save your time and money.

JoeBanzai

<< <i>I would just save your time and money. >>



+1

hookem

<< <i>In my opinion, you could swing a numerical grade on the Palmer, because of the set its from. >>



If I do sub this, do you think I should trim the left side to square it more on the bottom?

hookem

Looks like you guys are confirming what I feared!

Often times we overvalue our own cards and I am probably doing that this time