Grades In! Surprised to see a 64 on my Oak Tree Shilling.....

Tallpaul000 · May 17, 2013 3:53AM

Concur with keeping them together if you can. Cant do much about what goes on at ther graders except ask for a regrade.

Flash · May 17, 2013 3:58AM

<< Maybe someone in China will see them and make fake copies

>>

As opposed to a genuine copy?

johnny9434 · May 17, 2013 5:16AM

someone had a tough day that day

IrishMikey · May 17, 2013 5:27AM

I am going to guess that these two coins were both changed at the Quality Control stage. This would
have been by an experienced numismatist. However, the person fixing the labels would not be, and
they simply got switched. Yes, someone should have caught it, but they didn't.

Give PCGS the opportunity to correct the mistakes, and hope that YOUR next mistake does not get plastered
all over someone's message board. Not a firing situation, just a humorous one.

CoinJunkie · May 17, 2013 5:43AM

<< 

<< 

<< While this is certainly amusing, it's also scary. For example, consider two 1892-O Morgans submitted together, assigned grades of 64 and 65, and then slabbed as 65 and 64. >>

I dunno, sounds like a wash... >>

Not when one coin is deserving of the 65 and the other is deserving of the 64. The 64'd coin gets in a mechanical error 65 holder and the 65 coin gets a 64 holder and is sent back for regrading, then there's potentially 2-65's in holders now. A big jump in price. Not good for the person who bought the 64 coin in the 65 holder. >>

What part of "

" was unclear?

fastfreddie · May 17, 2013 6:57AM

At least your coins were shipped back to you - could have been worse and sent to China.

I would call immediately and arrange for a return and some freebies. This does nothing to help with the PCGS goodwill.