Hall of fame sets
ludedude
Posts: 146
If you request a "hall of fame set" for example a "1974 Topps HOF" (in my case hockey) do you include coach cards?
0
Comments
ON ITS WAY TO NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92658
If the card depicts the person in the role that got them in the Hall of Fame, the card should be included in the Hall of Fame set.
So.....
Any card of Walter Alston that depicts him as a manager should be in that Hall of Fame set, since he's in the Hall as a manager.
Same thing for Tom Lasorda, Earl Weaver, Sparky Anderson, etc.....
Along those lines, the 1954 Lasorda, 1959 Anderson, etc..., should not be in a Hall of Fame set, since those depict the men as players, and they were not inducted as players.
Also, the 1970, 1971 and 1972 Ted Williams cards should not be in the Hall of Fame set, since he was not inducted as a manager.
Regarding the OP's question about 1974 Topps hockey, the Scotty Bowman card should be in any Hall of Fame set, since it depicts him as a coach, and he's in the Hall of Fame as a coach (and I believe it is his "rookie" card).
Steve
"Notes: The Topps HOF year sets can include players, managers, owners, pioneers, comissioners and referees."
It doesn't show "coach", wonder if this is just a mistake? I will email PSA.