Anyone care to share experience on review subs to psa?

mattinglymint23

I have a few I am thinking about and curious if people have a view on the process or experience with good or not so good results?
Cards on my plate are some 56 topps in 8 that I think might get an 8.5 (star cards)
Some 71s too. Possibly an Jeter sp. Is it worth the money or is it a fools errand for a normal collector to try this? Thoughts?

RipublicaninMass

Contrary to popular belief, I sent my first six reviews/crossovers last week. I will update here when they come back

mattinglymint23

Thanks. Good- meant to mention crossover too. Keep me posted and good luck.

mattinglymint23

On a bgs cross over to psa I would assume that a bgs 9.5 has a ten shot depending on the sub grades on bgs side. I have read some success stories on the board. Would think that corners and centering are more critical to be 9.5+ over surface?

Bosox1976

The juice has to be worth the squeeze. I am about 10% on reviews, and more like 35% on crackouts.

I would think that if you went 10% on the cards you are listing, you'd come out ahead.

edit: Crossovers are tougher than reviews when it comes to bumps, at least in my experience.

JustinsShoebox

I have sent in 3 review orders - approximately 12 cards total. All but two bumped. Puts me at an 83% rate. The card has to be worth it, though, and I would be sure about it before I did it.

I posted the last two cards a few days ago here.

Justin