Help On Grade- 63' Mantle & 69' Ryan

orioles93

I just sent this in for grading. Not sure what to expect. Does it have a chance at a 4? Everything is really nice about the card except the crease on the bottom middle. Will this automatically make it a 3 or less?



Also how bout this Ryan? Off center top bottom, and has a slight border chip on the left side left of his elbow. Other than that , really nice.

WalterSobchak

The crease is prominent enough that I would expect a 3- but I don't think a 3.5 or 4 is out of the question.

JustinsShoebox

3 on this one.

Justin

Piggs

That's a tough call, it's a really nice clean picture and centering is nice. I'm going to say 3.5 or 4 because of the clean image. Good luck with it. Doug

MiniDuff

Before I read a word on the thread, I looked at the card and saw a 3. Good luck, it has nice eye appeal.

bobbyw8469

That is a great looking 3...maybe even a 3.5. Hard 4.

itzagoner

i like it as a 4. good luck.

Dodgerfanjohn

The Mantle is a 5 without the crease.

I think the crease makes it an automatic 3.

The Ryan, like everyone else, I'm not sure about. A 6.5 seems reasonable, but maybe a 7 too.

JustinsShoebox

The Ryan is a 5 without a qualifier. 6 on a very good day.

Justin

WalterSobchak

I say 7OC on the Ryan.

JoeBanzai

I like the Ryan. I would definitely grade both.

Ryan 6-7 Mantle 3-4

Joe