Which ones of these would you have graded by PSA ?

Smittys

totallyradd

there's no reason at all to have Aaron, Kaline, and Banks rookie cards left unslabbed, no matter what condition. My first submission to PSA had all those Topps cards (minus the Aaron). Most came back as 4 and 5's but my Williams came back a 1. Completely worth it in my opinion. The others are probably worth it as well. IMO.

CNote

Why can only one get slabbed?

ydapd

If they were mine, I'd have these graded -

54 Topps - Williams #250 , Kaline, Aaron, Mays, and Robinson

50 Bowman - Williams and Robinson . possibly the Spahn and the Parnell too

scmavl

I'd slab all of the '54 rookie cards, Mays, Robinson, Williams yellow), and any other stars that you think would grade a 5 or better. I wouldn't bother with slabbing any of the cards with paper loss.

Great cards!

jnorlund

I echo the posts about stars. Raw stars just don't have the value they once did. Takes grading to get them to the level they once were.