Ok i think of my self as a good trader but then i see this....
vittleboy
Posts: 2,975
"We're sorry, vittleboy
Your application for membership in Trader's Retreat was denied by the community's manager."
I have seen the member list at Trader's Retreat and i am 100% sure i have more refs then them and i have been here longer then alot of them. Ugh you know this is pushing me to just go to collecter empire and no were else. Sure i am really pissed that i didnt get in but Trader's Retreat could have given me a reason so i leave now so i can get a reason.
Your application for membership in Trader's Retreat was denied by the community's manager."
I have seen the member list at Trader's Retreat and i am 100% sure i have more refs then them and i have been here longer then alot of them. Ugh you know this is pushing me to just go to collecter empire and no were else. Sure i am really pissed that i didnt get in but Trader's Retreat could have given me a reason so i leave now so i can get a reason.
0
Comments
Ebay ID: mysteryman152
"Kid, get off me! Go back to school"
eat this, nikobe
Glenn Robinson Auto Collection 7/21
Glenn Robinson Auto Collection 7/21
Tha Finger ... Tha Stunner ... Tha Legend.
JSA
ps, funny how ur applicantion said, i will understand either way if im let in or not............then u post this on CU........
I will wait for ur response
Co Creator and Founder of the Scooby site/Trader Retreat.com/ sportscardinfo.com/ hoopscollector.com and the TR network.com
http://donniebaseball23.tripod.com/
Wantlist on Site
REFS Johnscottanthony,injun01, haliguy, FatKat, autobilia,awaltz,coachvinny, raf12,thematrix31,duncangal, Kenny21, and many more
Tell me your kidding me in that response??
E!!
Ref's:
Johnscottanthony*****
Mpower
AI3TheAnswer
Sporto1633
Duncangal
THiTo
Kenny**
Baljit
Ejones
etc...etc..
Glenn Robinson Auto Collection 7/21
http://donniebaseball23.tripod.com/
Wantlist on Site
REFS Johnscottanthony,injun01, haliguy, FatKat, autobilia,awaltz,coachvinny, raf12,thematrix31,duncangal, Kenny21, and many more
http://www.traderretreat.com/community/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=120&SearchTerms=RichyPF32
Wantlist:
Jonathan Bender
Evan..(TR)
Ref's:
Johnscottanthony*****
Mpower
AI3TheAnswer
Sporto1633
Duncangal
THiTo
Kenny**
Baljit
Ejones
etc...etc..
You have had some suspect trades and some negative post here on CU, that has led me to believe that you wouldnt be a good fit for TR currently. If you would like me or possibly MPower to go to CU archives and pull up the info im talking about than i will. I personally reimburse anyone that is ripped off by a trade on TR. WIth this in mind that causes me to be cautious with who we select. That goes for you too Jbugs, but i believe Evan is handling ur case. I hope you understand my positon Vittleboy and my job to protect the members of my site. If u dont......u dont.......
Jbugs, ur comments and rage, only confirms u have no place on TR. Your language is uncalled for, but again proves you dont belong at TR where we dont tolerate that kind of stuff. SO suffice to say, ur comments say it all.
Cardnyou, i have no battle with you. You have done nice things on CU. And i will leave it at that. We have no clicks or buddy system on TR. Your rep has to speak for itself.
Ilya, I think of CE as a good site, but if you continue to let suspect and probelmatic traders in your site, my personal feeling is that you will have major problems.
We may not have as many members as CE, but thats because we hand select our members, and dont leave the door open for all to come. Being a TR member yourself "Ilya" you should appreciate that.
JSA
Co Creator and Founder of the Scooby site/Trader Retreat.com/ sportscardinfo.com/ hoopscollector.com and the TR network.com
Tha Finger ... Tha Stunner ... Tha Legend.
"C'mon baby light my fire!"
Now, she REALLY digs that...especially coming from her man Derrick! LOL
and where the hell do u see me scamming anybody?? huh?? get ur shi* straight before u say anything!
remember, we get your email/ip/and other info that will be used for banning/busting you..
Ebay ID: mysteryman152
"Kid, get off me! Go back to school"
eat this, nikobe
<< <i>Vittleboy,
You have had some suspect trades and some negative post here on CU, that has led me to believe that you wouldnt be a good fit for TR currently. If you would like me or possibly MPower to go to CU archives and pull up the info im talking about than i will. I personally reimburse anyone that is ripped off by a trade on TR. WIth this in mind that causes me to be cautious with who we select. That goes for you too Jbugs, but i believe Evan is handling ur case. I hope you understand my positon Vittleboy and my job to protect the members of my site. If u dont......u dont.......
Jbugs, ur comments and rage, only confirms u have no place on TR. Your language is uncalled for, but again proves you dont belong at TR where we dont tolerate that kind of stuff. SO suffice to say, ur comments say it all.
Cardnyou, i have no battle with you. You have done nice things on CU. And i will leave it at that. We have no clicks or buddy system on TR. Your rep has to speak for itself.
Ilya, I think of CE as a good site, but if you continue to let suspect and probelmatic traders in your site, my personal feeling is that you will have major problems.
We may not have as many members as CE, but thats because we hand select our members, and dont leave the door open for all to come. Being a TR member yourself "Ilya" you should appreciate that.
JSA >>
Ahhh, I thought this was over and I tried to say out of this .. but.. it's time.
JSA, what do you know about CE and vBulletin software and it's capabilities? I can tell you plenty about MSN community because it is all the same. Answer this, how long will it take TR to get to 100 users? Anyone can provide e-mail addresses as references just like Rusnak did here with about 25 different e-mail addresses. Do you call up Yahoo and hotmail and verify all of those free e-mail addresses. Unless the user is on CU (which seems to be the main recruiting grounds for TR), how will you be able to verify their references?
"Suspect" and "Problematic" users can be banned with extreme prejudice. Let me tell you a little bit about vBulletin which is the best forum money can buy. Let me break down the process for you. For starters, everything is logged and I do mean everything. as a matter of fact, here's a stat from this month. "beckett.com 45 2%" which means an employee or employees from Beckett checked the site 45 times this month which is 2% of total hits. "upperdeck.com 2 0%" someone from Upper Deck stopped by twice. Ok, now when someone registers to CE, they have to give a valid e-mail address. Their account can't be activated unless they give a valid e-mail which that e-mail includes a link. You should know that, you registered to CE. Next, while on CE, your IP is logged into the software (how do you think we verified that BMWRacing was Brandon Rusnak?). Even if a person uses a Yahoo, Compuserve, Hotmail, etc. address, the software still logs your primary IP address which is where you connect to internet. Another thing installed, but haven't had a chance to test it, is that when you register, it checks to make sure your IP address isn't already in the database. If your IP address is in the database, it won't let you re-register again (preventing multiple usernames). When a person gets banned, they are banned by their e-mail address AND their IP address. So, they are locked out completely. I installed a point system on CE whereas when you complete a successful and satisfactory trade on CE, 1 point is given to each user which acts as a feedback rating. We also have a referal system in which each person is assigned a link to use (which we may use that as one of the contests when the Box Breaks & Review) stats which tells who referred who. Now, CE has been up since February 25th and I guarentee you that TR has had more problems that CE.
Back to security. Even if someone tries to hack into the admin control panel, it sends me an e-mail telling me what they entered, their IP address, what time they tried it, how many times, etc. Now, all I have to do is a nslookup on a person's IP address to find out where they are coming from. As in anywhere, I check up on all of our users. If they've ripped off someone, it will definately be posted somewhere. I'm basically just the admin and let the moderators handle the site (who are doing a great job at it).
And since you talk about the security of CE, let's talk about the growth of TR. Just like any admin, you want your site to grow. But how is a site going to grow if it has no way of growing (since most people get rejected). How long will it take for it to get 100 users? 2 years? What % of those users are not from CU? I hate the comparison of CE and TR because CE is a site which includes a forum. TR is more of a trading community. Can't compare the 2. It's like apples and oranges. Seems you are comparing your site to just CE's forum. That's like comparing a card shop to a mall. There may be a card shop in that mall, but there are a bunch of other things in there besides a card shop. So, I'm not going to go through this "comparison/competition" thing again.
Another thing that is holding TR back. A lot of companies and places don't take sites seriously that doesn't have their own unique URL. I'm not here to bash TR, because for the users to come here and defend it, it must be a great place to trade. But at the same time, I'm not going to listen to people criticize CE when they are completely clueless to what is going on at CE. Don't let the surface fool you. Now, as you and I know, everyone is capable of ripping someone off (people have been kicked from TR, right?). But once that happen, they are banned. Depending on the circumstances, while they are banned, if they make good on their trade, they can be re-instated and may be required to send first on trades. I installed something like Soccer. "Yellow" card and "Red" card which will let everyone know who is on a probationary basis. Also installed a "Honest Trader" award which let's everyone know who has traded and never had ANY problems. Just to share forum info with the users, they can click on "Statistics" which is located at the top of the main forum page to see the top referring sites, the top recruiters, the most used browsers, etc.
Bottom line, there is a ton of security options that you don't see. It's nowhere near as wide open as CU. So, before you go judging, do your research first.
autobilia nows his stuff.
Glenn Robinson Auto Collection 7/21
In my own conversations with JSA, he's never had anything to say but good words and opinions about CE. I think you're being a little overly defensive here. I'm sure you'll disagree with that sentiment, but I still thought I'd have my say!
Peace...
my website
References: Batman34, TopofOhio, McDee, JRCCrum, JSA, Sporto, Derrick, many others.
<< <i>Autobilia,
In my own conversations with JSA, he's never had anything to say but good words and opinions about CE. I think you're being a little overly defensive here. I'm sure you'll disagree with that sentiment, but I still thought I'd have my say!
Peace... >>
No, my problem is, I hate when people criticize how CE runs and is completely clueless about how it operates. It may look wide open like CU on the surface, but you'd be very surprise on what's inside. I have no beef or problem with TR. My only focus is on CE and the success of the site. Don't have time to worry about what everyone else is doing and this so called "competition" that people seem to bring up. The initial argurment was vittleboy and jbugs vs. TR. JSA is the one that brought up CE and the "suspect and problematic users that could cause major problems". Yet, he knows absolutely nothing about vBulletin. Now, if that was to come from Ilya who was running vBulletin a while back, I probably wouldn't have lashed out as much. It's not being overly defensive. I'm just tired of hearing this so called "competition" thing and people talking about things they know nothing about.
I'd be the first to admit to cluelessness in myself and the last to suspect it of you, autobilia
my website
References: Batman34, TopofOhio, McDee, JRCCrum, JSA, Sporto, Derrick, many others.
As a member of TR, i do not at all feel as though we are "held back" by denying applicants with any sort of questionable feedback. You seem to think that TR is handi-capped by it's not having 2000 members, but that is actually a bonus. A smaller group equals a closely-knit group, and i have made many friends there. A sure way to get into TR is make a few successful trades with trusted members of the group (most of which are active here and on other sites as well, so they are easy to find). So your praising vBulletin and downing the e-mail-reference system TR uses is irrelavent. If someone applies to TR with a lot of references, but none of which are with traders that the moderators KNOW they can trust, then they are usually denied. So if someone applied using 100 obscure e-mail addresses (ie Rusnak) then they will probably be declined if no trusted members have traded with any of them. I guess you saw this as an opportunity to display your technical knowlege of computer junk and to throw completely meaningless Beckett.com statistics at us, but no TR members are bashing other sites, so settle down. I am not sure who you are trying to impress
Erik
"Stop talking, negotiating,
Your feeble attempts at world peace
Give me a %#@*ing break
Need worldwide genocide, planetary suicide
And when the whole damn world is dead
there's your %#@*ing peace"
What i do question is letting members in CE that are known suspect or bad traders here on CU. If you already know from what you have seen on CU that a trader is suspect at best, why let them in? How long will it take to get 100 members? Hmmmm took us about 3 months as we have 117 members now with another 17 pending. Growth? Growth is not at the forefront of our priorities. We care about getting good traders who enjoy the hobby and want to trade. Being the biggest site with the most members, doesnt consistute it being the best. Just my opinion. Our site is a family, its more important for us to get the "right" members, than the most. You have some impressive new security systems.......They are nice and im sure they work well. But at TR its all about ur Rep, what u did last year or what u did today. It all counts for or against you. So Id rather stick to our old system of letting your repuatation talk for you, rather than having a great securtity mouse trap, to catch the fleet of foot scammer. Your system stops a bad trader from reentering (if i understand correctly) Ce "after" they rip someone..........Our old fashion check your refs system, stops the scammers "before" they get in. But again this is my opinion.
I dont want a war with you or CE, not because im trying to avoid conflicts, but because i believe we are both trying to create the same thing. "A safe and fun site to trade,sell and talk about sports on". Im a member of CE and am well aware of what it has, just as you have managers of CE who are members of TR.
I dont think there is any need to tear each other apart. I really believe we are on the same team. If you want to continue to put CE up against TR, so be it as Im game. But i think we would be more useful helping others separate the good traders from the bad.
JSA
Co Creator and Founder of the Scooby site/Trader Retreat.com/ sportscardinfo.com/ hoopscollector.com and the TR network.com
<< <i>lol...
I'd be the first to admit to cluelessness in myself and the last to suspect it of you, autobilia >>
Heh, since I put up CE, there seem to be a bunch of friction from the start. First with Hobbygab. That's because I use to be an IRCOP on collectorchat which is now Hobbygab. When collectorchat went down, we were meeting on Undernet which had tons of netsplits. As time passed, we could never get a direct answer to when collectorchat was going back up, so I just posted here. Then when people were complaining about getting ripped off, I promised a few users I would put up a site as an alternative to CU with moderation. Heh, 2 softwares, 4 database restarts, 100+ hours of coding and modifying, 4 moderators, etc. later.. here we are. I guess I was more ticked than anything because we've been down this road before and I thought it was over with. Apparently not.
So what JSA that mean i am a bad trader. So all my refs me nothing i guess i should just stop tradeing because you know who is bad or good. thanks i need to know for sure.
Glenn Robinson Auto Collection 7/21
But I know what JSA is saying and I agree -- the trader's retreat is just that - a RETREAT where trusted friends get together and trade, chat, or hang out.
Autobilia may have created an empire, but I like our little banana republic at TR...
my website
References: Batman34, TopofOhio, McDee, JRCCrum, JSA, Sporto, Derrick, many others.
JSA
Co Creator and Founder of the Scooby site/Trader Retreat.com/ sportscardinfo.com/ hoopscollector.com and the TR network.com
<< <i>Hmmmmmm, I think you took my comments wrong . I was in no way putting CE down or trying to compare TR to Ce. Both are good functional sites.
What i do question is letting members in CE that are known suspect or bad traders here on CU. If you already know from what you have seen on CU that a trader is suspect at best, why let them in? How long will it take to get 100 members? Hmmmm took us about 3 months as we have 117 members now with another 17 pending. Growth? Growth is not at the forefront of our priorities. We care about getting good traders who enjoy the hobby and want to trade. Being the biggest site with the most members, doesnt consistute it being the best. Just my opinion. Our site is a family, its more important for us to get the "right" members, than the most. You have some impressive new security systems.......They are nice and im sure they work well. But at TR its all about ur Rep, what u did last year or what u did today. It all counts for or against you. So Id rather stick to our old system of letting your repuatation talk for you, rather than having a great securtity mouse trap, to catch the fleet of foot scammer. Your system stops a bad trader from reentering (if i understand correctly) Ce "after" they rip someone..........Our old fashion check your refs system, stops the scammers "before" they get in. But again this is my opinion.
I dont want a war with you or CE, not because im trying to avoid conflicts, but because i believe we are both trying to create the same thing. "A safe and fun site to trade,sell and talk about sports on". Im a member of CE and am well aware of what it has, just as you have managers of CE who are members of TR.
I dont think there is any need to tear each other apart. I really believe we are on the same team. If you want to continue to put CE up against TR, so be it as Im game. But i think we would be more useful helping others separate the good traders from the bad.
JSA >>
Who are the "suspect" users. Anyone is capable of ripping someone off. I don't care what they did last year. Let's see... does mpsteelerfan ring a bell? Yes, he was a great trader. I and many others have traded with him. But look at him now. You can never put full trust into a person because of their past history. It's all day-by-day. And to be honest, no members know what all CE has. There is a lot going on that users don't see. When I said 100+ hours of coding and modifying, that's no exaggeration. As I said in a previous post, CE is an alternative to CU and I'll leave it at that.
Glenn Robinson Auto Collection 7/21
Erik
"Stop talking, negotiating,
Your feeble attempts at world peace
Give me a %#@*ing break
Need worldwide genocide, planetary suicide
And when the whole damn world is dead
there's your %#@*ing peace"
As far as hits..and member wars..or who's site is better. I don't really care about any of that. What I care about is the collecting hobby. What I care about is what my NAME is on...and that's TR. What I want is for someone to look at TR and say.."HEY..Evan is one of the Managers and that there's always good trading goin on there!" That's what I care about.
Evan
Ref's:
Johnscottanthony*****
Mpower
AI3TheAnswer
Sporto1633
Duncangal
THiTo
Kenny**
Baljit
Ejones
etc...etc..
Everyone take a look
Glenn Robinson Auto Collection 7/21
<< <i>Autobilia,
As a member of TR, i do not at all feel as though we are "held back" by denying applicants with any sort of questionable feedback. You seem to think that TR is handi-capped by it's not having 2000 members, but that is actually a bonus. A smaller group equals a closely-knit group, and i have made many friends there. A sure way to get into TR is make a few successful trades with trusted members of the group (most of which are active here and on other sites as well, so they are easy to find). So your praising vBulletin and downing the e-mail-reference system TR uses is irrelavent. If someone applies to TR with a lot of references, but none of which are with traders that the moderators KNOW they can trust, then they are usually denied. So if someone applied using 100 obscure e-mail addresses (ie Rusnak) then they will probably be declined if no trusted members have traded with any of them. I guess you saw this as an opportunity to display your technical knowlege of computer junk and to throw completely meaningless Beckett.com statistics at us, but no TR members are bashing other sites, so settle down. I am not sure who you are trying to impress
Erik >>
no TR members are bashing other sites? Until now.. hasn't happened since CE started (remember the back and forth feud me and McDee2 went through?). Since then, I thought everything was over and life moved on, but apparently, some baggage was stored. Not going to beat a dead horse on this one. By you never saw me saying anything about TR until this. And my response was directed to JSA's comment and nothing else. Not meaning to said sarcastic, but since JSA made the comments, let speak for himself. No disrespect.
EVAN .......TR
Ref's:
Johnscottanthony*****
Mpower
AI3TheAnswer
Sporto1633
Duncangal
THiTo
Kenny**
Baljit
Ejones
etc...etc..
Well, I hooked up the Bravo Delta to the Supreme Access center. Then after that I installed a hyperactive proton generator to the Bravo Delta. Not to mention the trusty duel stud micro-chips. Then we have to remove, repair, and install the clip bindings which helps the turbo thruster combine into the turbine connection.
LOL. Ok well maybe I exxagerated A LITTLE.
~Austin
I'm back - you better believe it
<< <i>I'd respond to autobilia if I knew what he said.
But I know what JSA is saying and I agree -- the trader's retreat is just that - a RETREAT where trusted friends get together and trade, chat, or hang out.
Autobilia may have created an empire, but I like our little banana republic at TR...
>>
No, I meant CE and TR has 2 totally different objectives. But people seem to ignore that and try to see it as competition. Correct me if I am wrong; TR is a trading site, right? Basically, a site to trade comfortably with other users. CE is a sports hobby site. Yes, there is a forum for people to post, chat, trade, etc., but it is also a site for in the mail autograph collectors which is ran by memphis who is doing a great job , NBA direct which is a basketball/streetball site hosted by Ilya & AI3, and of course sports hobby info, interviews, etc. I see it like a Mall and a card shop. Neither is better than the other, but they both have different objectives.
<< <i>Autobilia - Some of the "less fortunate" in the computer world, think you are saying this:
Well, I hooked up the Bravo Delta to the Supreme Access center. Then after that I installed a hyperactive proton generator to the Bravo Delta. Not to mention the trusty duel stud micro-chips. Then we have to remove, repair, and install the clip bindings which helps the turbo thruster combine into the turbine connection.
LOL. Ok well maybe I exxagerated A LITTLE.
~Austin >>
Now, crank it up and see if it works
Glenn Robinson Auto Collection 7/21
As I said in my reply in ilays and jas's post there is alot more than trading at CE some come there just to talk sports play trivia or whatever..So it would'nt be right to deny them that..But there if/when they make a trade post it's watched over and all pending traders have been and will be warned about a suspect traders past...
As was the case with Yanksfan way back when CE was still on the PHB server it was posted publicly that Yanksfan was welcome to trade but due to his past he should trade on a send first basis..From ther the choice was up to him and any that wanted to make a deal with him..
ALL GOOD ROOKIE CARDS FROM ANY SPORT!!!
REF: DPSPORTS, SPEEDMASTER, nascar20, McDee(x2), Epag, Bradley25, Duncangal, Representcards, Drew(x2), Ahares(x2), Kenny(x2), 8kobe, jrrcrum, vittleboy, Remster, swides, robdemkis, LJMAYA, IversonMiles, BlackbirdXXX,RichyPF32
Bottom line is CE is and excellent site with some awesome software..and TR is an excellent site and that's it. Both are better in their OWN ways..and BOTH have their disadvantages...
SO, LET'S LET THIS GO ALREADY.........PLEASE,
Evan....
Ref's:
Johnscottanthony*****
Mpower
AI3TheAnswer
Sporto1633
Duncangal
THiTo
Kenny**
Baljit
Ejones
etc...etc..
Autobilla, Id like to burry this hatchet and move on, its pointless, we all have our views, we all care for our sites. The backing i got from my Tr brothers today is enough to let me know that we are moving in the right direction at TR, as are u at CE. So if my comments somehow offended you, I apologize as i am sensative to how my site is viewed as well.
Hondo, if we didnt before, I'd like to personally apologize to you. It appears we were given incorrect info on you and because of that you were denied. I hope you can appreicate our attempt at keeping our site safe and accept my apology.
JSA
Co Creator and Founder of the Scooby site/Trader Retreat.com/ sportscardinfo.com/ hoopscollector.com and the TR network.com
Ebay ID: mysteryman152
"Kid, get off me! Go back to school"
eat this, nikobe
Ps ilya I owe you a chrome rc lol.
Glenn Robinson Auto Collection 7/21
It's in the mail bubba