Any chance this is a proof 1930 florin?

candy2012mustang

I bought this the other day - The coin is very high relief - the obv. has an odd "shine" like that of early proof US coinage.

The rev. is totally toned in a way that looks like it was in a display box (like the 1950's-1960s south african proof sets - the rev. always get toned from the "velvet")

What do you think?

Senex

Don't think so.

wybrit

Although the head is very nicely struck, my first impression is that it is not a proof. Take a look at the milled edge and see if the teeth are sharp and straight - that might be a good clue. Also, the finish should be mirror-like. It could well have been in a velvet box for a long time, but I would expect the finish to be even darker than shown if it was a proof.

Here is a picture of a 1927 proof florin (same obverse and reverse) for comparison. Unfortunately I took the picture of it being housed in an Airtite, where it still resides, so the edges aren't visible - and I can't get at it in short order.

candy2012mustang

The edge has very straight reeding.

Jinx86

Hey shouldnt that be in the bag of stuff your mailing me? Haha just kidding, looks like a very nice struck piece.

candy2012mustang

not if I paid more than melt for it(:

7Jaguars

Sorry to break the news, but no definately not. I am only aware of one proof 1930 florin in private hands. That would have been a real find. I know this series well....

candy2012mustang

Besides the fact there are only a few out there, why do you say that it is def. not a proof?