anyone want to venture a guess?

lightningboy

Purely speculation of course, but I am thinking about buying a card that should comfortably grade a PSA 5. No sales of any grades on VCP other than a PSA 5 with a qualifier that sold for $270. I've heard that qualifiers tend to drop the value down to that of 2 grades lower (PSA 3 value ?). That being said, what might be a guess at what this card would sell for if it grades out at PSA 5? Thanks, Tom

digicat

Depends on the card and how it looks. Centering and overall eye-appeal are important.

lightningboy

Its a rare old golf card with ver nice centering. It would be a solid PSA 5 with a PSA 6 by the right grader.

JW

Can you give us more information about the card to help you with the value? Is it an ungraded Tom Morris?

Golfcollector

Yes be very careful on the 1901-1902 ogdens morris cards. if that is what you are after. I have graded numerous ones over the years.

1) the black borders are sometimes retouched.

2) PSA is very inconsistent on these cards in my opinion. I have had ones graded over the years that look to be like PSA NM 7's and they come back 4's and other ones that look rough around the edges and I think will be PSA 3-4 range and they come back PSA 6's _ I also have a number that have seemed to be what I thought they would be.

PSA 5's on this issue is really freaking tough.....These cards are brutally tough, have centering issues, are sometimes trimmed, surfaces crack etc...basically I am saying is that I gave up trying to accurately predict the grades on these cards from the Ogden's series a long time ago. I just try to get nice ones, send em in, get em authenticated and hope for the best

lightningboy

Yes, it is an ungraded Ogdens Guinea Gold.