grade opinion?

BasherBoy

I'm sorting through some 58's trying to figure out which ones to have graded. I know it's hard from a scan but thought I'd see what the opinions were. LMK what you think for grades and if you see any that don't make sense to sub please advise. Also, would most of these work for the bulk special this month?

mikelowell25

grade them all; they all look to be at least 7's/7.5's depending on the corners, maybe a couple would 8

the wilhelm is a screamer

BasherBoy

I'd love to get an 8 on the Wilhelm, that's one I still need for my team set

mikelowell25

there's no reason it shouldnt get an 8; the centering is good, and unless the bottom right corner is worse than it looks, it should 8 no problem.

i would give it an 8.5 based on the color and overall pack-freshness of it; how is the gloss?? does it have that wet, pack-fresh look??

BasherBoy

I think it is one of the sharper cards I've come across in the group. looks like it just rolled off the press. I don't think the scan does it justice.

mikelowell25

frankly, i dont think any of the scans do your cards justice; they are so pack-fresh looking its incredible!!

sure, some of the corners arent perfect and the centering on some is a bit off, but who cares???? they look like they were printed yesterday!!!!

i think its more exciting seeing virgin raw cards like these than ones in holders; you can hold them in your hands and smell that old card smell!! (which is better than a new CAR smell, or a new card smell, for that matter).

makes me want to find someone who has a shoebox full stashed away in their attic!!

BasherBoy

honestly it cost me a few bucks for this group, but it's the most fun I've had with my cards since I was a teenager.

leadoff4

I'd grade them all...at least the ones you've scanned here.

firedawg45

Sharp cards. Grade them all. Good luck

BasherBoy

how about these couple? Cards are nice, not thrilled with the centering though. worth grading or keep raw?

Mickey71

Overall....I say great cards and grade them; but your scanner kind of stinks. I see potential focus and print issues galore the more I look on a few of them. Klu has alot going on in the focus/print area.

BasherBoy

thanks for the opinion. I know my scanner is junk, I've tried changing some settings and it doesn't seem to help.

fiveniner

do them all.

BasherBoy

still scanning these, have ran across a few more that I think I might send.







the Howard looks really nice to me.