Find the Cameo...how good is your eye?

ModCrewman

Below are photos of some coins from my recent submission to PCGS. It was a disappointing submission for me overall, though the scores covered the misses.

Here's the challenge for you...Only ONE of these coins received a Cameo designation from PCGS...Which one is it?

SanctionII

My guess is the third 1966 SMS nickel.

If that is incorrect my two back up guess is the second 1965 SMS half.

AngryTurtle

<< <i>My guess is the third 1966 SMS nickel.

>>



Some of those Frankies look good too, as my backup.

DanielBoone

My guess would be the 1960 cent.

seanq

<< <i>My guess is the third 1966 SMS nickel.

If that is incorrect my two back up guess is the second 1965 SMS half. >>




Those are the exact two coins that stood out to me as well.


Sean Reynolds

tightbudget

Some of these are real close but at the end of the day, I think the third 1966 SMS Nickel made the CAM designation.

messydesk

First choice is the 2nd 1966 nickel, second guess would be the 2nd 1965 half.

michiganboy

My guess is second 65 half

stealer

Third nickel

MarkInDavis

I'll go with the 60 Franklin.

Jcarney

Third sms jeff or 1960 cent.

SUMORADA

.........1967 sms 10c.........

ziggy29

Nickel #3.

OldEastside

IMO I have never seen a TRUE SMS CAM Jeff even the ones
so designated as Cam by the TPG's have the break in the
Step Area when they lack steps

Steve

AUandAG

<< <i>

<< <i>My guess is the third 1966 SMS nickel.

>>

BaseballAbs

The first ,1960 Lincoln.

lordmarcovan

Ooh.. very tricky and challenging.

I too will guess the third '66 SMS nickel.

Wabbit2313

1965 Lincoln.

Crazy4Coins

I'll go with the '67 Roosevelt Dime

Sonorandesertrat

The third 1966 nickel.

johnny9434

ok, my guess is the 1960 franklin

FullCameo

67 sms dime

keets

the first 1965 Kennedy Half-Dollar.

pmac

Second '65 Kennedy.

bolivarshagnasty

<< <i>Second '65 Kennedy. >>

I agree!!!

noow

2nd kennedy

Lehigh96

<< <i>the first 1965 Kennedy Half-Dollar. >>



+1

SAM5969

1960 Franklin Half or the 3rd 66 Nickel - both seem very close if not fully cameo
Scott

georgiacop50

1960 Frankie is Cam

JazzmanJAB

<< <i>2nd kennedy >>

SUMORADA

.......................sooooooooooo..........the correct guess is...................................................is..........................naaa............everyone was right, they are all cam.............

and the winner is,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

ModCrewman

Didn't mean to leave everyone hanging, I was at a high school football game tonight.

I was expecting that a lot of different coins would get some votes, but there were actually more different opinions than I expected.

The only one that received the designation was the 3rd 1966 Jefferson nickel.

messydesk

Interesting. The windows on the 2nd 66 nickel are frosted while those on the 3rd are clear. Thanks for posting this.

SanctionII

What did I win???????????