Would you bother getting this Peace Dollar graded?

AUandAG

If not, why not? Just curious, common date for sure. Has a very, very slight toning behind her head, in
her hair and to the SW of her chin. That pesky yellowish tone.
bob

MidLifeCrisis

Since I'm a pretty big fan of TPG grading - yes.

No downside.

Baley

Not sure the world needs another 1923 peace dollar graded MS63

BryceM

If you think she's a 5 maybe - at economy level. If you think she's a 3 or 4, no, since there is no upside, just expense. I'm looking on my iPhone, so it's hard to know, but I don't see it as worth it.

lasvegasteddy

nah i wouldn't grade her either...why not...hmmm...because you're a friend...i'd like to see ya save all those grading fees
no need t put her up as junk silver on the bst...i'll meet ya at starbucks and give ya melt plus a grande of your choice...

Treashunt

pass.

coinkat

Its great for a type set album. I think 64 is fair- just doubt it is worth doing

Tdec1000

Yellowish haze could be PVC residue. Let that one sit in acetone over night.

Tiny

Nope

lcoopie

looks lustrous with few marks a clean cheek, could be a 65 so yes.

Steve27

Nice coin, but not worth the fees.

AUandAG

<< <i>Yellowish haze could be PVC residue. Let that one sit in acetone over night. >>



Yes, thought that as well and did soak her for about 4 hours. No change. It's toning.

Great comments and I haven't decided to send or not but probably will as I do think
she's a 65. I've had a lot of 64's and this one is better than them. Meets the definition
of 65, I think.

bob

Baley

My original comment was based upon the initial, larger pictures posted, which showed a lot of marks on the reverse, in the central wings and the left fields.
It does look better in these smaller pics

AUandAG

<< <i>My original comment was based upon the initial, larger pictures posted, which showed a lot of marks on the reverse, in the central wings and the left fields.
It does look better in these smaller pics >>



That's funny. Photobucket enlarged them and then reduced them on their own!
I saw that as well and wondered what I did wrong to get the huge pics and then
they resized to the present images. Weird...

bob

Jinx86

So what have we learned from this....Sell on ebay with small pics....it hides more.

Thanks for the lesson.

philographer

Buy a nice 65, sell this one and put the money toward the purchase.

Edward

stealer

<< <i>Buy a nice 65, sell this one and put the money toward the purchase.

Edward >>


Bob usually knows what he's talking about when it comes to silver dollars, just saying