PSA and Peyton Manning ttm signed cards

cardsnbeads

How can these not pass? The autographs look real. They are not a stamp or autopen. Is it b.s. Heck I got a Peyton Manning signed 1999. Is PSA failing them on purpose or is something up?

raiderguy10

I've tried 6 TTM Mannings (from his rookie year up to this year). I only have had 1 pass - and that was one I got this season when he was hurt. Not sure if the others are ghosts or not.

jswieton

I have no idea what the problem is with all of the TTM requests failing. They look identical to the one I just got signed at the SunTimes show last week. I actually video taped Manning signing my card and got it JSA certified just to be sure it finds its way into a PSA holder when I sub it. I am going burn the video onto a disk and include it with my sub just to be sure there is no question regarding its authenticity.

yankeeno7

If your Mannings dont pass, I would send them to JSA/BGS or JSA/SGC and see how they do. I dont know what JSA is doing with the TTMs but I would think its worth the gamble to try one and if it passes, do the rest.

Jmhockey23

I've seen JSA passing them more than PSA. PSA passed 1/4 attempts for me.

cubfan89

They also don't seem to pass in person autos.
Failed one I got in person & failed a buddies card he got Manning to sign right after a pre-season game in Detroit a couple years ago.
He even emailed them a cellphone pic of Peyton signing it after.

Southsider

Sounds like PSA needs some new exemplars for Manning's signature.

raiderguy10

TTT - wondering if anyone else has any information on JSA and if they pass the cards or not.