Poppage on one of my subs - PSA 10 ! Scan added

dtkk49a

I actually pulled this out of a pack back in 1998. Will post a scan next week.

Line # Item # Cert # Grade Description Type

1 1 20064960 GEM MINT 10 1998 TOPPS CERTIFIED AUTOGRAPH A10 PEYTON MANNING BRONZE-PSA/DNA CERTIFIED

Dialj

Congratulations on the 1/1. Can't wait to see the scan!!

Dboneesq

AWESOME! Please post pics when it arrives.

CDsNuts

Not really a pop 1 but a nice card nonetheless.

Lee

Probstein123

congrats

gumbyfan

Looks like a pop 19 to me.

dtkk49a

I love how some people here like to poop in your Easter basket. It is a pop 1 . It's the only PSA/DNA currently graded 10.

gumbyfan

<< <i>I love how some people here like to poop in your Easter basket. It is a pop 1 . It's the only PSA/DNA currently graded 10. >>



All of the autographs are certified by Topps. Congrats on your PSA flip that's a pop 1. As for the card, its a pop 19 PSA 10.

Scottiec2288

Congrats....show scan when you get it back.

dtkk49a

Say what you want Gumby, but the Pop report clearly designates it as a Pop 1. Stop being jealous and move onto another post.

CDsNuts

No one's trying to poop in your easter basket, but it's a pop 1 by technicality only. You just happen to be the only one that submitted this card using the auto authentication service instead of the straight card grading service. The reason others don't use the PSA/DNA service on modern pack-pulled autos is because everybody knows the autos themselves are legit.

If it makes you happier about the card then go ahead and call it a pop 1, but don't fool yourself into thinking it's any more valuable than the 18 PSA 10s that are not PSA/DNA authenticated.

Lee

LodiBrewFan

Don't sweat Gumby, he is always trying to be negative. Its best just to ignore those types. Sweet card!

gumbyfan

<< <i>No one's trying to poop in your easter basket, but it's a pop 1 by technicality only. You just happen to be the only one that submitted this card using the auto authentication service instead of the straight card grading service. The reason others don't use the PSA/DNA service on modern pack-pulled autos is because everybody knows the autos themselves are legit.

If it makes you happier about the card then go ahead and call it a pop 1, but don't fool yourself into thinking it's any more valuable than the 18 PSA 10s that are not PSA/DNA authenticated.

Lee >>



+1

gumbyfan

<< <i>Say what you want Gumby, but the Pop report clearly designates it as a Pop 1. Stop being jealous and move onto another post. >>



You pegged it. I'm jealous. How can I go on?

dtkk49a

I'd like to know how others feel about this. Is it indeed a pop 1 or a pop 19 ?? is it worth more than non DNA graded card?
PSA shows it as a one in the pop report.

Scottiec2288

Lee is right.I thought you had the only auto but if the other 18 have the auto its a pop 19. I don't collect modern autos so I didn't understand, I know some cards are #ed 1 of 1 or 1 to 99 and so on. Its still a great card and a PSA 10 is awesome..congrats

LodiBrewFan

As soon as the first PSA/DNA card sells for a premium on Ebay, you'll see a flood of graded and authenticated modern auto cards. Don't let the haters bring you down.

MBMiller25

It's a pop 19. I don't think it's worth any more or less with the PSA/DNA flip. Congrats none the less, that's a nice card.

DavidPuddy

<< <i>It's a pop 19. I don't think it's worth any more or less with the PSA/DNA flip. Congrats none the less, that's a nice card. >>



+1

Good lord LodiBrewFan. Stop stalking Gumby.

CDsNuts

Actually I take it back, you probably could get a premium for it by putting pop 1 in an ebay title, because technically you are telling the truth and the idea of owning a pop 1 signed Manning RC would appeal to some collectors. At least I would try and get a good price for it.

As far as long term value, I don't think it will be worth any more or less than the others PSA 10s. I seriously wasn't trying to diminish how nice of a card it is, because it's one of only a handful of Manning signed RCs and will always command a good price in any grade.

Lee

pdub1819

<< <i>It's a pop 19. I don't think it's worth any more or less with the PSA/DNA flip. Congrats none the less, that's a nice card. >>



I just found this out last week. I have a Harmon Killebrew that I sent in to PSA/DNA instead of the regular card grading service. If I would have known that I could sent it in with the regular service, I would have saved myself some money. Oh well, I still like the card and it looks nice in the blue flip.

dtkk49a

Thanks Lee. Anyone have an idea what its worth?

grote15

Whatever you do, make sure you consign it to Rick..

dtkk49a

I will call PSA in a few ask them if its a 1 or a 19.....

dtkk49a

Hi, according to PSA, its a pop 2 PSA/DNA card but there are 18 non PSA/DNA of the same card graded PSA10

here is the scan: