Looking for a Good Brick-n-Mortar dealer in Indianapolis

MMR

My most esteemed PCGS coin colleagues:

I will be passing through Indy next weekend and I am looking for recommendations on a good honest coin or PM dealer to sell some of my stack to. I will be selling mostly: Silver Bars, ASEs, Maples, and some GSA Peace dollars.

Who do you recommend and how much back of spot for the bars should I expect? I have a mix of 10, 5, 1, and half ounce bars. How about the rolls of ASEs and the maples, what would be a fair price relative to spot for them?

And the GSAs? should I just hang on to those? I know there is a niche market for them on eBay, but I don't have the desire to mess with that right now.

Thank you in advance for any recommendations you may have.

Respectfully,

MMR

Lehigh96

I would contact Matt Dinger at Lost Dutchman Rare Coins. I can't tell you what type of offer to expect but in my experience, Matt is an honest and knowledgeable dealer. I would call him before you get to the shop so that you can get an idea of the prices he would be willing to offer.

OldEastside

Have you tryed home depot

Sorry, hehehe

Steve

MMR

I didn't realize Home depot had a coin department. I remember the 5 and dime used to have one.

LanceNewmanOCC

.
there are several around indy and if you are going to make the trip i'd advise hitting 2-3 of em

probably best to call cuz dealers may be out of their shops
.

edited to add:

get an early start and then hit the downtown for a great lunch/dinner

or keystone area offers some great choices without having to drive too far
.