Is this too big?

JoeBanzai

Just got this back from PSA, thought it would grade higher. Should I have trimmed off all of the yellow border? Anyone see anything that would bring it down to a 6? Thought it would get an 8 or 9.



Back is clean. Piece of dirt on scanner.



Card has some very very slight scratching on surface, but no creases or dents.

Joe

wolfbear

Looks like there is a small clump
still attached to the lower right hand corner of the card.

scotgreb

IMO definitely not cut too big -- not to mention these look way better cut this way.

I expect it's the fuzzy corner and the surface -- given those I still think it merits a PSA 7 (assuming no wrinkles, etc.)

JoeBanzai

I noticed the "chunk" of fuzz left over from cutting, but didn't want to mess with it, fearing I would just make it worse. NO wrinkles and the scratches are extremely minor.

I think it looks great cut this way and deserves at least a 7.

Oh well.

Joe

Hank36

It looks better than this hand-cut 6, although I'm not sure PSA realized this was hand-cut: