Options
S.B.A. QUESTION?ON MODERN TYPE SET(1950-Present)

What is the difference in these two requirements?
Susan B. Anthony Dollar - Narrow Rim (1979) Proofs
Susan B. Anthony Dollar (1979-1999) Proofs
The 1997 Proof is a Narrow Rim,would one coin do for both spots?
Susan B. Anthony Dollar - Narrow Rim (1979) Proofs
Susan B. Anthony Dollar (1979-1999) Proofs
The 1997 Proof is a Narrow Rim,would one coin do for both spots?
The Victorian Collection
EMAIL:
relictrader@suddenlink.net
EMAIL:
relictrader@suddenlink.net
0
Comments
EMAIL:
relictrader@suddenlink.net
For some life lasts a short while, but the memories it holds last forever.
-Laura Swenson
In memory of BL, SM, and KG. 16 and forever young, rest in peace.
If they wanted 2 SBA's why don't they say on one (1980,81,99) and 1979 on the other...........?
Gary
EMAIL:
relictrader@suddenlink.net
For some life lasts a short while, but the memories it holds last forever.
-Laura Swenson
In memory of BL, SM, and KG. 16 and forever young, rest in peace.
Modern Type Set (1950-Present)
Issue Weight
Lincoln Cent - Wheat reverse (1950-1958) 2
Lincoln Cent - Memorial reverse, bronze (1959-1982) 1
Lincoln Cent - Memorial reverse, zinc (1983-Present) 1
Jefferson Nickel (1950-Present) 1
Roosevelt Dime - Silver (1950-1964) 2
Roosevelt Dime - Clad (1965-Present) 1
Washington Quarter - Silver (1950-1964) 2
Washington Quarter - Clad (1965-1998) 1
Washington Quarter - Silver Bicentennial (1976) 2
Washington Quarter - Clad Bicentennial (1976) 1
Washington Quarter - State reverse, Silver (1999-Present) 1
Washington Quarter - States reverse, Clad (1999-Present) 1
Franklin Half Dollar (1950-1963) 2
Kennedy Half Dollar - Silver (1964, 1992-Present) 1
Kennedy Half Dollar - Accented Hair (1964) 3
Kennedy Half Dollar - Silver Clad (1965-1970) 1
Kennedy Half Dollar - Clad (1971-Present) 1
Kennedy Half Dollar - Silver Bicentennial (1976) 2
Kennedy Half Dollar - Clad Bicentennial (1976) 1
SMS Piece (1994 or 1997 Nickel or 1998-S Half Dollar) 3
Eisenhower Dollar - Silver (1971-1974) 2
Eisenhower Dollar - Clad (1971-1978) 2
Eisenhower Dollar - Silver Bicentennial (1976) 2
Eisenhower Dollar - Clad Bicentennial, Type 1 reverse (1976) 2
Eisenhower Dollar - Clad Bicentennial, Type 2 reverse (1976) 2
Susan B. Anthony Dollar - Narrow Rim (1979) 2
Susan B. Anthony Dollar (1979-1999) 2
Sacagawea Dollar (2000-Present) 1
American Eagle Silver Dollars (1986-Present) 1
American Eagle Gold, any denomination (1986-Present) 1
American Eagle Platinum, any denomination (1997-Present) 1
Commemorative Half Dollar (1982-Present) 1
Commemorative Dollar (1983-Present) 1
Commemorative Gold $5 (1986-Present) 1
Commemorative Gold $10 (1984-Present) 2
EMAIL:
relictrader@suddenlink.net
Here's a copy from a post of mine a while back, and it's also the same info I sent BJ at PCGS. Note the ambiguity about the 1999 coins -- your call as to what to do on that. I'm not actively pushing anything at PCGS.
Numbers before the date are the PCGS coin numbers.
---------
NARROW RIM:
9571 - 1979-P SBA$ MS
9572 - 1979-D SBA$ MS
9573 - 1979-S SBA$ MS
99589 - 1979-S SBA$ Type 1 PRDC
99590 - 1979-S SBA$ Type 2 PRDC
WIDE RIM:
99571 - 1979-P SBA$ Wide Rim MS
9574 - 1980-P SBA$ MS
9575 - 1980-D SBA$ MS
9576 - 1980-S SBA$ MS
9578 - 1981-P SBA$ MS
9579 - 1981-D SBA$ MS
9580 - 1981-S SBA$ MS
99592 - 1980-S SBA$ PRDC
99594 - 1981-S SBA$ Type 1 PRDC
99595 - 1981-S SBA$ Type 2 PRDC
1999 REDESIGN:
9581 - 1999-P SBA$ MS
9582 - 1999-D SBA$ MS
99596 - 1999-P SBA$ PRDC
The 1999 are a complete re-design from the "classic" 1979-1981 design, so calling them Narrow Rim or Wide Rim does not make sense.
I believe the 1999 coins are currently classified as Wide Rim in the PCGS type sets, though if anything they are more like a Narrow Rim in appearance.
More importantly for type set purposes, the difference between a classic and 1999 SBAs is more dramatic than the relatively minor difference between the Wide Rim and Narrow Rim designs.
I believe any of the following would make far more sense for type set purposes than what is currently being used (2 SBAs in type set, a Narrow Rim and Wide Rim):
1 SBA in type set:
Any date
2 SBAs in type set:
Any 1979-1981 date (Classic design)
Any 1999 date (1999 redesign)
3 SBAs in type set:
Any 1979 Narrow Rim
Any 1979-1981 Wide Rim
Any 1999 date
EMAIL:
relictrader@suddenlink.net
Last e-mail I received had everything straight at PCGS -- 1979 proof coin or 1979 PDS for the Narrow slot, 1980-1999 proof or 1979 P Wide or 1980-1999 MS coins for Wide Rim slot.
I know that you feel that the 1999 slot should be separated off, but at least they have the 1979's sorted out correctly now.
Keith
WEEKS FROM NOW OR AS SOON AS THIS POST DISAPEARS THE QUESTION WILL COME UP AGAIN & AGAIN...
(1980-1999 proof or 1979 P Wide or 1980-1999 MS coins for Wide Rim slot)....VIA kEITH'S POST
PCGS SHOULD REWORD THESE TWO SLOTS,,,,WHAT DO YOU THINK?........................GARY
EMAIL:
relictrader@suddenlink.net
Hey, I need something to keep me out of trouble.
Of course if they followed my (far more sensible) suggestion for a 2 coin representation:
Susan B. Anthony Dollar - Classic design (1979-1981)
Susan B. Anthony Dollar - Redesign (1999)
Voila! No confusion.
Keith