Will it grade at our host?

stealer

The most unfortunate scratch from the nose down

magikbilly

Ouch. I like the bit to the right though I hope it grades but it may not.

Eric

AnkurJ

Genuine holder due to scratches.

magikbilly

I always forget the Gennie....

Eric

ModCrewman

I wouldn't think so...quite the die crack there.

rawmorgan

I like it, but I don't think it will grade.

mozin

Interesting coin, but PCGS should not grade it.

2manycoins

i dont think it will grade

originalisbest

You know, I'm on the fence here -- I think it'll grade without the gennie label; the scratch is in one of the worst focal areas it can be in; yet, it is old, well-blended, and this is a huge image of a tiny coin. My guess, yes, it'll grade, though it might be a coin toss. Were it a brighter/newer scratch, no doubt it'd genuine.

ColonialCoinUnion

I think it will grade (if submitted on a sunny day with the wind at your back), but even then it will be netted down considerably.

291fifth

Genuine, scratched. It looks like a coin that a typical Sunday bourse dealer would have in his stock at full price, waiting for a "live one" to come along.

DorkGirl

<< <i>I think it will grade (if submitted on a sunny day with the wind at your back), but even then it will be netted down considerably. >>



Yeah, what he said...

Barndog

if past performance is any indicator, I say yes

PerryHall

<< <i>Genuine holder due to scratches. >>

halfhunter

<< <i>You know, I'm on the fence here -- I think it'll grade without the gennie label; the scratch is in one of the worst focal areas it can be in; yet, it is old, well-blended, and this is a huge image of a tiny coin. My guess, yes, it'll grade, though it might be a coin toss. Were it a brighter/newer scratch, no doubt it'd genuine. >>





Pretty much exactly what I was going to post.

HH

originalisbest

Geez 291fifth, are you ever not grumpy? I do think it'll grade, especially per the example Barndog posted.

stealer

<< <i>Genuine, scratched. It looks like a coin that a typical Sunday bourse dealer would have in his stock at full price, waiting for a "live one" to come along. >>


Guess I'm a "live one". Thank goodness at least it's an R-5

291fifth

<< <i>Geez 291fifth, are you ever not grumpy? I do think it'll grade, especially per the example Barndog posted. >>



Grumpy? When am I ever grumpy? I just think of myself as being accurate.

braddick

MilkmanDan

Braddick that cracked me up, what is that from, an old Jerry Springer episode?

jimbux61

Yeah good one Braddick. I think it is a live feed from a local car dealership!