Updated with grade:Practice grading on this 1938 P Walking Liberty Half

MVC

Actual grade is MS65

Just got this back from PCGS. Will reveal actual grade later



For a super large picture click here and then click the coin

LeeBone

I`ll start.

63

BryceM

65+

MsMorrisine

pics are too small for an accurate determination

golfer72

Great luster but lots of hits on Libertys leg and the gouge on the eagle breast. 63

291fifth

Poor quality photos. No better than 63 due to hits on liberty's leg.

LeeBone

A pic of my 38 (D mint tho) with a mark on the obverse in a similar area




Hence my guess as a 63

JBN

Appears lustrous. I'll guess 64.

magikbilly

No grade from those pics from me Booming luster obscuring detail with contrast/white balance off to these old eyes...guess 64+?

Eric

Walkerguy21D

Luster carries it to a 64, despite the obverse chatter.

lkeigwin

<< <i>Luster carries it to a 64, despite the obverse chatter. >>

Ditto.
Lance.

Cam40

soutwesbullancorn call it a gem, which technically is a 65 but, maybe my standards
are a couple points tighter.

Lucanus

I'd say MS65. I've seen 65's with that much chatter, I think the luster carries the coin.

Doug

phnatacc

AU 58

lordmarcovan

Would prefer bigger pix, but I'd say 64 easy, and 65+ wouldn't surprise me. Has a very Gemmy look.

Ahrensdad

64+

breakdown

<< <i>I'd say MS65. I've seen 65's with that much chatter, I think the luster carries the coin.

Doug >>


I like this answer.

dlmtorts

The luster is good but too many hits for 65. I say 63 maybe 64.

joebb21

63+ 64-

Rollerman

Solid MS64+ outside chance at MS65 it seems to me.
Pete

keyman64

64...nice reverse.

lasvegasteddy

i'm in the 64 crowd except for...
if it has that line vertically when tilted making it an au58

robkool

MS64...