Received some coins back from PCGS. Want to GTG? GRADES POSTED

ajaan

Coins were mailed 12/20 and arrived today. Pretty good considering the holiday season.

Coins received by PCGS 11/16 World Modern Service

The only 1958 1/2d VIP Proof graded by PCGS. No cheating.



A trio of nicely toned SP Canadian Dollars:

SYRACUSIAN

Wow, Don, the Canadian dollars look outstanding. I had misjudged them the first time that you had posted them.

Congrats on the halfpenny. I believe that it too deserves a better image.

Hussulo

Super coins Don

I'll have a stab at it.

No1 PF64
No2 PF66 CAM
No3 PF65
No4 PF65

The pictures of the Canadian coins are great and show off the colours really well but its hard to tell if they are CAM or DCAM.

Aethelred

The first one is fake, the rest are G-4 with AT

weresteve

Were it one of my submissions ... the first one would be Genuine/Cleaned and the others would be AT ...


Tho my guesstimates would be ...

PR63
PR65
PR67
PR64

Steve

coinkat

PR63

ormandh

I really like the 2nd 1971 dollar!

MacCrimmon

<< <i>The first one is fake, the rest are G-4 with AT >>






cookie!

TwoKopeiki

<< <i>The first one is fake, the rest are G-4 with AT >>

Pokermandude

It's so hard to guess the grades on higher grade coin pictures, especially toned ones. But my guesses are:

1958 - PR65
PR66
PR67
PR66

TwoKopeiki

Shroomster, you forgot to post the actual grades after updating the title!

ajaan

1958 1/2d PCGS PR63RB I was surprised it RBed. I thought BN, but then again, I thought PR64

Canadian cased dollars inorder:

SP66
SP66
SP64

Kind of confused on the last one. I guess the lesser attractive toning cased them to downgrade the coin.

ajaan

<< <i>Shroomster, you forgot to post the actual grades after updating the title! >>


Roman, I can only type so fast with one finger.

TwoKopeiki

<< <i>

<< <i>Shroomster, you forgot to post the actual grades after updating the title! >>


Roman, I can only type so fast with one finger. >>



Congrats on the grades! I'm a bit surprised about the last Dollar, as well.

Pokermandude

<< <i> Congrats on the grades! I'm a bit surprised about the last Dollar, as well. >>



Same here. These are usually very high grade coins, as they hardly ever left their cases over the last 30+ years. I'd guess that they assigned the lower grade due to the "spots" on the obverse.

7Jaguars

Not in agreement with many of the Brit graded proof pieces. A 63 should have fairly significant hairlines at least in the field. I have seen some Record Proofs in 65 that I think warranted a 67, disagree with BN vs. RB vs. R, etc.

coinkat

congrats-

I did not offer thoughts on the Dollars- Ajaan, they are attractive but at a certain level and these fall within that level, it becomes hard to offer an opinion from an image

ajaan

<< <i>The first one is fake, the rest are G-4 with AT >>


Merry Christmas to you too aethelbore.