Grade-O-Rama - Grade opinions on these Morgans please

ModCrewman

A friend has asked me to photo a few Morgans of his that he is looking to sale, and post them for the grade opinions of the board. Thanks for your help!

You can cut and paste this list for the grades (or Net/Details Grades where appropriate):
1. 1891 -
2. 1891-CC -
3. 1892 -
4. 1892-CC -
5. 1892-S -
6. 1893-S -
7. 1894 -
8. 1894-S -
9. 1895-S -
10. 1897-O -
11. 1898-S -























DISCLOSURE - I may be helping him sell them also.

Rampage

My guesses:

1. 1891 - MS61
2. 1891-CC - Fine details, DAMAGED
3. 1892 - AU55
4. 1892-CC - VF20
5. 1892-S - XF details, CLEANED
6. 1893-S -G4
7. 1894 - AU details, CLEANED
8. 1894-S - VF25
9. 1895-S - Good details, DAMAGED
10. 1897-O - AU55
11. 1898-S - AU55

Rampage

Well, how close did I come? A+? A-? B? Missed 0? Missed 2? Missed 5? This was actually fun to do by the way...

TPRC

First impressions

1. 1891 -----ms-62
2. 1891-CC -f-12 det--dam--rim dings
3. 1892 -----au-55
4. 1892-CC ---f-12
5. 1892-S ---au-50 det--cleaned
6. 1893-S ---ag-3
7. 1894 ----au-50 det--cleaned
8. 1894-S ---vf-30 det--cleaned
9. 1895-S ----g-6 det--damaged
10. 1897-O ---au-55
11. 1898-S - --au-58

rec78

1. MS-62
2. F-12
3. AU-50
4. F-15
5. VF-35-cleaned
6. AG-3
7. EF-45
8. VF-30
9. G-6 damaged
10. AU-53
11. AU-58

The opinions above are strictly my own and have not been influenced by other posters.
Bob

ModCrewman

A bump for the Monday morning crowd.

DennisH

1. 1891 - MS62
2. 1891-CC - F15 (may be cleaned and/or scratched obverse)
3. 1892 - AU55
4. 1892-CC - VF20 (may be cleaned)
5. 1892-S - VF35 (may be cleaned)
6. 1893-S - AG03
7. 1894 - XF40
8. 1894-S - VF35
9. 1895-S - Good-04 (damaged, graffiti on obverse)
10. 1897-O - AU55
11. 1898-S - AU58

ModCrewman

Would like a few more opinions if anyone would be willing to chime in.