My first poppage... Updated with scans

StickNutzman

1 1 18803212 EXCELLENT-MINT 6 1967 TOPPS 150 MICKEY MANTLE Card US
2 1 18803213 N8: MISCUT 1968 TOPPS 177 METS ROOKIES J.KOOSMAN/N.RYAN Card US
3 1 18803214 VERY GOOD 3 MC 1968 TOPPS 177 METS ROOKIES J.KOOSMAN/N.RYAN Card US
4 1 18803215 GOOD 2 1952 TOPPS 175 BILLY MARTIN Card US
5 1 18803216 MINT 9 1984 FLEER UPDATE U-27 ROGER CLEMENS Card US
6 1 18803217 MINT 9 1984 FLEER UPDATE U-93 KIRBY PUCKETT Card US
7 1 18803218 EXCELLENT-MINT 6 1966 TOPPS 126 JIM PALMER Card US
8 1 18803219 N1: EVIDENCE OF TRIMMING 1982 TOPPS TRADED 98T CAL RIPKEN JR. Card US
9 1 18803220 NEAR MINT-MINT 8 1968 TOPPS 280 MICKEY MANTLE Card US
10 1 18803221 EXCELLENT-MINT 6 1968 TOPPS 50 WILLIE MAYS Card US
11 1 18803222 N8: MISCUT 1968 TOPPS 50 WILLIE MAYS Card US
12 1 18803223 EXCELLENT-MINT 6 1965 TOPPS 477 CARDINALS ROOKIES F.ACKLEY/S.CARLTON Card US
13 1 18803224 EXCELLENT 5 1965 TOPPS 477 CARDINALS ROOKIES F.ACKLEY/S.CARLTON Card US
14 1 18803225 VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT 4 1969 TOPPS 500 MICKEY MANTLE LAST NAME IN WHITE Card US
15 1 18803226 GOOD 2 1959 TOPPS 10 MICKEY MANTLE

UPDATE: Some scans below.

Here's some... centering on some not the greatest but it is what it is.



I'll probably sell these at some point:


And here's the other Ryan in question. Any chance they would ever grade this?

ThoseBackPages

Still pretty good first sub!

hows the centering on the Puckett?

divecchia

Not too bad for a first sub...

You will get better with time and experience...

Donato

StickNutzman

Here's a few scans I took before submitting. Sorry for the white background...

ThoseBackPages

Nice looking Puckett. is there a slight tilt? (it could be just the scan throwing me off)

StickNutzman

I dont think there's a tilt... I'll get a better scan of it when it comes back. I also have another one that I didn't submit that is more off center. BUT CAN YOU BELIEVE THE RIPKEN WAS TRIMMED!?!?! That just ruined my day.

Counselor

Check to see if Ripken measures correctly. If it does, send it back in. I have resubmitted cards that received EVID TRIM and they have come back graded on second try.

StickNutzman

What about the two N8's? I think the Ryan at least was what you'd call a "diamond cut"... Will they eventually grade that as a MC?

TonyC

I know that it is possible, but how likely is it that someone trims a modern card? Do the graders ask themselves that question before they slap it with an EOT?

StickNutzman

Bump for scans... what are my options for the Ryan card? Keep it in a Card Saver forever? I might try to sell those 2 miscut Ryan rookies and try to pick up a nice PSA 8 sometime down the line.

Also I just found this... no idea if mine would be a 9 with all the centering and cut issues but the corners are nice. Would this be comparable? Ryan 9 (OC)