2006 Reverse Proof ASE

John91C

So I have a a set of the 20th anniversary with the reverse proof in PR70, PR70DCAM, and MS69 all with the 20th anniversary label.

I have no idea what to do here or if I'm just SOL...the Reverse Proof and PR70DCAM both have MILK SPOTS...these have been stored in a food saver bag vacuumed up for over 4 years (maybe 5) and rarely taken out of the tote I have them in.

Am I just left with having a milk spots on them or will PCGS honor any type of guarantee?

Thanks for any help on how to deal with this situation...pretty ticked off right now!

MercCrazy

I'd send them in for a spot review.

dbcoin

PCGS guarantee is the best in the business. They will honor the guarantee and give you a few options (money for the coins, downgrade with money difference, attempt to crack out and dip). You won't lose out.

Milk spots is why I no longer collect the ASE's. Be glad you had them in PCGS slabs.

coinsarefun

Send them in for review, they are very good about this problem.
I had a few MS and PR 70's that developed milk spots, they could not be removed so they gave me fair market value.

pitboss

I was lucky, I did not get any milk spots and have sold all of my anniversary sets at a good profit.

TwoSides2aCoin

Despite milk spots (pity about them), the reverse proof is one of the coolest coins the U.S. Mint's designed, since the bi-metallic coin of 2000 (in my opinion).

Swampboy

I LOVE the reverse proof.
Th only one I have is in an original set but that's good enough for me.

John91C, once in a thread like this our hosts jumped in and said something t othe effect "We don't want spotted ASEs in our holders."
Send 'em in!

John91C

Thanks for all the replies...I'll send them in and see if they can remove them...if not then I guess I'll have to get fair market value. Man I hate to let these coins go...love the reverse proof!