Question - What other holders will PCGS consider for Cross-Over?

GRANDAM

Will PCGS consider any other holders besides NGC for cross-over? How about ANACS or ICG coins?

I can seem to find the answer for this on their Web Site

Thanks, GrandAm

------------------------------------------------

I did find this but it doesn't say and I thought I read on this Forum awhile back that they were only considering NGC coins for cross-over at this time? Can anyone confirm or deny this?

Crossover: Use the "Crossover" service for coins previously graded by another grading service. Submit the coins in the holder to PCGS. We will grade the coins and put them in a PCGS holder only if the PCGS grade meets or exceeds the other grading company's grade (unless specifically instructed differently by you). You cannot specify a higher minimum grade. If the PCGS grade is lower than the other grading company's grade, we will return the coin to you in the original holder. MS/PR 70 coins must have a minimum grade of 69 or lower.

TomB

Any.

123cents

It just NGC that has got picky.

MsMorrisine

even the homemade ones.

it's just a matter of what grade it will get.

ambro51

True. I submitted a piece once in an ICG holder, it came back in the same holder with a little pcgs tag in a bodybag with Genuine Cleaned on it.

ianrussell

<< <i>True. I submitted a piece once in an ICG holder, it came back in the same holder with a little pcgs tag in a bodybag with Genuine Cleaned on it. >>



I like when they give a reason - even though it didn't cross, you get an idea of what the graders were thinking.

- Ian

GRANDAM

<< <i>It just NGC that has got picky. >>



----------------------------------------------

So are you saying that NGC will only consider PCGS Coins for cross-over and not other brands?

I though I read something about somebody doing something

BTW for the record I would never consider crossing PCGS Coins to any other holder but I would buy a hard to find coin in another holder and try to cross to PCGS if I really needed the coin

GrandAm

ambro51

<< <i>< True. I submitted a piece once in an ICG holder, it came back in the same holder with a little pcgs tag in a bodybag with Genuine Cleaned on it. >> I like when they give a reason - even though it didn't cross, you get an idea of what the graders were thinking. - Ian >>





ummmmm, well yes, sort of. When I showed this coin to JA he said "this coin isn't cleaned".

so, I dunno, I think they flunked it because of a planchet lamination.

TwoSides2aCoin

Had some luck with PCI graded coins at PCGS. Am a little scared to try my luck with the SGS brand in "70" holders, though.

PerryHall

<< <i>Am a little scared to try my luck with the SGS brand in "70" holders, though. >>



PCGS won't cross 70 coins in any slab since it's impossible to verify that the coin is perfect while it's within a slab.

ajaan

I tried to cross an ACG MS63 RED, cross at any grade. It didn't cross. I cracked it out, submitted it raw --- PCGS MS64RD.

fcloud

Crack 'em out before you send them in. It makes life a lot easier.

GRANDAM

Another question:

Rather than start a new thread.

Fee's on ATB 5 oz Silver Coin.

Modern @ $14

Oversized Holder @ $20

1st Strike @ $18

Handling Fee @ $8

Return Shipping @ $16.95

Total = $76.95

Is this correct?

I wouldn't send this coin in but it is flawless and should go MS69 or MS70.

It is the Yellowstone Collectors Version.

Anyone know of grades on these yet?

Thanks, GrandAm