1953 Stahl Meyer Mantle experts

captainthreeputt · May 20, 2011 3:05AM

I see on ebay all the time 1953 Stahl Meyer Mantles PSA 1mk for over $3k, and straight PSA 1's for anywhere from $3750-8000. They are always there but never sell. What should a PSA 1 with a qualifier sell for?

Thanks for the help,

Brian

earlycalguy · May 20, 2011 5:10AM

the card trades in limitied quantity so it's tough to know an accurate price.

my only experience was a PSA 1 with no qualifiers that I sold for approx. 2k

Probstein123 · May 20, 2011 5:29AM

Latest Auction Prices for: PSA 1.5 - Average Price: $3,862.23
Listing Type: Show:
Date Auction Link Seller Buyer Bids Price Extra
2/12/10 Goodwin $3,862.23
========================================
Latest Auction Prices for: PSA 1 - Average Price: $1,540.50
Listing Type: Show:
Date Auction Link Seller Buyer Bids Price Extra
3/5/10 Legendary Image 17 $1,540.50
5/29/09 Huggins & Scott Image 18 $1,840.00

earlycalguy · May 20, 2011 5:40AM

i think the legiondary price is the one I purchased (and resold for 2k)...the day the auction was ending a forum member was posting links to the auction touting the card saying he was the high bidder and he really hoped he would win. when actually he was the consignee of the card to Legiondary

Dboneesq · May 20, 2011 5:44AM

<< <i>i think the legiondary price is the one I purchased (and resold for 2k)...the day the auction was ending a forum member was posting links to the auction touting the card saying he was the high bidder and he really hoped he would win. when actually he was the consignee of the card to Legiondary >>

Well THAT sucks. Do you have the link to that thread?

Edited to add: I found it. What an "Overrated" thread it was.

captainthreeputt · May 20, 2011 5:50AM

Thanks for the info guys.

Brian

judgebuck · May 20, 2011 11:38AM

I love the card. Does anyone know which Stahl Meyer Mantle is the most desirable - 1953, 1954, or 1955? According to this SCD Catalog, the 1955 is the most valuable. Don't think I've ever seen one, though.

Dboneesq · May 20, 2011 11:47AM

<< <i>I love the card. Does anyone know which Stahl Meyer Mantle is the most desirable - 1953, 1954, or 1955? According to this SCD Catalog, the 1955 is the most valuable. Don't think I've ever seen one, though. >>

Judge - 1955

judgebuck · May 20, 2011 12:18PM

Thanks, Doug. I think this is the same picture as the 1953. I don't think I've ever seen any Stahl Meyer Mantle graded 2 or higher for sale any where. I'm sure it has happened, but only rarely.

captainthreeputt · May 20, 2011 12:34PM

I have to believe the most desirable is the 1953. Joe Orlando has that year in the top 250 Sportscards in the hobby set.

Brian

earlycalguy · May 20, 2011 1:02PM

the 53' has almost 3 times the cards graded as the 54' and 55' - 28 to 10/11 cards

captainthreeputt · May 20, 2011 2:18PM

Interesting. Once again thanks for the info.

Brian

dstudeba · June 14, 2011 4:44AM

54 and 55 are both tougher than the 53

1953 Stahl Meyer Mantle experts

Comments