Which would you rather have...Martin Brodeur's PSA 10 Score Canadian or American Rookie

artistlost

Thoughts?

Anyone know the pop on PSA 10 for both or the past sales records?

mathew

otwcards

Canadian... The Canadian issue has always held a premium in PSA 10. There are 481 American PSA 10's out of 3419 graded (14.1% of the population) versus 198 Canadian PSA 10's out of 1186 graded (16.7% of the population).

ThoseBackPages

Gotta do both IMO

If not both, then *I* would go American because i am in the US and prefer Topps to O-Pee-Chee

vladguerrero

Canuck

Boopotts

It depends on whether you want the card for the image on the front, or the text on the back. If French text gets you all heated and excited then buy the Canadian; if all you care about is having a RC of one of the greatest goalies ever than buy whatever is cheapest.

Ask yourself this: Why am I buying the card? And why is it important to me to have it in PSA 10? You answer those 2 questions and you'll know what to do.

akuracy503

who's Martin Brother?

akuracy503

jay0791

The psa required card is the Canadian version...so If it's for the reistry then buy the francais

hockeycrazy

I'd buy the Canadian. But I would wait another year at least as the price on these continue to plummet as the pop reports for PSA 10s continue to rise. Very similar to 1989 Topps or OPC Leetch rookie.

Sean1125

Neither Hockey sucks

artistlost

<< <i>Neither Hockey sucks >>



Thanks for your wisdom. I will start listing my collection tonight with low buy it now pricing to liquidate it quickly.

So glad you are a part of these boards to help me see the light.

m.

EagleEyeKid

The Canadian one for me. I like the red score logo and it has a better gloss
and just looks more vibrant to me.

digicat

<< <i>Thanks for your wisdom. I will start listing my collection tonight with low buy it now pricing to liquidate it quickly. >>



Nah, money sucks. Fire, on the other hand, is cool. Burn em!

Frozencaribou

Both Score issues from 1990 are so plentiful that it is only a matter of time for pop numbers to double or triple in PSA 10 for this card. I would say it will always be a desirable card, but not for an investment. Buy both, in time.

-Nathanael

Garabaldi

<< <i>

<< <i>Neither Hockey sucks >>



Thanks for your wisdom. I will start listing my collection tonight with low buy it now pricing to liquidate it quickly.

So glad you are a part of these boards to help me see the light.

m. >>



Always one d-bag in the group.

sportscardtheory

Canadian. No brainer.

Sean1125

<< <i>

<< <i>

<< <i>Neither Hockey sucks >>



Thanks for your wisdom. I will start listing my collection tonight with low buy it now pricing to liquidate it quickly.

So glad you are a part of these boards to help me see the light.

m. >>



Always one d-bag in the group. >>




"Thoughts?"


I gave my thoughts, if you didn't want my thoughts you shouldn't have asked for them in the first post

I like football you like hockey.

Edit because I can't spell worth a sh!t

jimrad

<< <i>Neither Hockey sucks
I like football you like hockey.

Edit because I can't spell worth a sh!t >>



I always laugh at someone that loves football.
The game takes something like 2 1/2 hours and there is only 12 minutes of actual action - so boring.

vbellier

The pop #'s for PSA 10's will skyrocket while the price will inevitably drop. I decided to get both versions but looking back that was silly. Canadian version for me -- like Jay said, the francais does it.