Let's PLAY...Which Gretzky rookie would you rather have?

artistlost

Both are O-pee-chee Wayne Gretzky rookies. Now, if you could buy only one. Which one do you like better?

A.



B.

EchoCanyon

If they're both graded the same, A

Garabaldi

The second one

Brick

First one.

YogiBerraFan

A

leathtech

centering looks better on "b"

54topps

The first one. The centering is not a good but the corners look sharper.

leftofdial

Assuming no counterfeits or any miscellaneous hanky-panky, I'd choose A over B.
I'll sacrifice the centering and maybe trade off some vivid color to avoid B's corner wear (on all 4) and also the wear on the middle of the right side

eagles33

i would choose B. i care more about centering than corners.

ThoseBackPages

<< <i>i would choose B. i care more about centering than corners. >>



This.

eyebone

assuming they are both legit.....A.

Garabaldi

A=PSA8(OC)
B=PSA7

thedutymon

Afternoon,

Neither.............for that kind of money I could get a Keg of Beer, Ton of Blow, a Hooker, and be occupied until next week.............Ah the memories,.......... Oh wait a minute, I'm not Charlie !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

YeeHah

Neil

Probstein123

A

Hallco

I'm very different than most collectors as far as I have zero interest in ever owning that particular card....but if I was buying it for someone else and I was asked to choose which one I felt was the better looking card....I would pick B.

cpamike

I am a corners guy so I would pick "A". It may be OC, but not that bad to take away from its eye appeal.

Morgoth

A it has better corners also the scan looks odd to me so the blury image could be that.

I think that upper left corner on B makes it an automatic 6 that centering and color don't make up for in my mind.

JohnnyD

"A" - Although B has nice centering, the corners - especially the top left - are just too ugly on B.

BunchOBull

Color, registry, and centering outweigh the corner issues...B.

tsalems1

A, the only thing that looks better to me on "B" is the colour

mexpo75

My 2 cents says A

edmundfitzgerald

Neither. They both look bad.

CollectorAtWork

I like the first one also.

CrazyMind2017

Corners mean nothing on an expensive card unless you're going for a 9 or 10. The vivid color and virtually perfect centering on B at a PSA 6 price make it the much better buy..... assuming A is a PSA 8(OC) and B is a PSA 6.

Regardless of grade, the eye appeal of B is astronomically better than A.

vladguerrero

is that an outbreak of print dots on B in the word EDMONTON?

WinPitcher

Hi Matt

A


Steve

hockeycrazy

Neither.

A = very off center;

B = bad corners. Honestly, OPC cut corner or not, that upper left tip on B is almost missing.

Brutal.

I have so far stayed away from most Gretzky's as I find them mostly over graded.

Dave

hookem

Got to B

artistlost

Thanks for all the replies. I am going to pass on them both and wait for the right one for me. Figure I only want to buy this card once so it should be the one I really want.

Thanks for all the help.

Also,

A was a PSA 7
B was a PSA 5.5

mathew

Autos4Alex

Where's that 5.5 for sale and how much is it?

Garabaldi

Those seem like tough grades for the both of them.

thehallmark

A. (neither)