2011 Topps Heritage variation thread: facts and speculation (2nd post has SSP pictures)

edit 3/31/11 - Topps announced the official short print & variation list - I'll update this post when I get a little more time.
I'll keep this thread updated as new information comes out. If I get a wild hair, I might even throw in some pictures.
The following compiles what is known about this year's Heritage, plus what is pure speculation on my part based on the original '62. If anyone can confirm something I've written is either correct or incorrect, I'd sure appreciate it. I'll update as new information trickles in. It's entirely possible that more is out there that is nowhere on this list.
* base Short Prints are 426-500.
* tinted variations. Green tints are not SSPs, but definitely rare. Red tints are exclusive to Target, while blue tints are exclusive to Wal-Mart. They can only be found on cards numbered 110-196.
* black bordered cards. Looks like these parallel the chrome cards, and are unnumbered. They are only available from Target's 3-pack rack packages.
* green refractors. These were inserted in hobby boxes. These boxes were inserted one per case - each pack in these boxes contains one green refractor. They are not numbered.
The Super Short Prints are becoming clearer, but some of the info below is still speculation. I based all of it on quirks that exist within the original '62 set.
#129
1962 was Lee Walls - he can be found looking both right and left. His looking left pose was also a green tint.
2011 is Carlos Quentin - if it exists, look for a looking left pose variation with a green tint
at this point, I don't see that a pose variation exists. The tint variations on eBay show the same portrait as the base card.
#132
1962 was the Angels team card - one variation had two floating heads inset in the photo
2011 is, guess what, the Angels team card. Hmm
confirmed as a simple green tint - lame, in my opinion. It would have been nice to have the two floating heads. Perhaps it exists as a SSP, though.
#134
1962 was Billy Hoeft, who had two poses. These poses weren't very distinct, but the regular one had a very distinct blue sky, while the green tint had... a green sky.
2011 is Brett Cecil - the one on eBay has has a VERY distinct blue sky. Hmm, guess we should be looking for a green sky, huh?
Cecil's green tint is a full frontal portrait, as opposed to the base card's somewhat side-view portrait
#139
1962 had four total variations: two poses of Hal Reniff (pitching & portrait - one a green tint) and two poses of Ruth (one a green tint). For the record, Reniff is also #159. Fun, huh?
2011 has a Joba, a Ruth, a Jackie, and probably another Joba with a pose variation. And of course #159 is Joba.
It has been confirmed that there are four different #139s this year, too. Babe has a base and a green tint, and Joba has a different pose than his base #139 - that pose is available as a regular card and a green tint. Both are SSPed.
#147
1962 was Bill Kunkel, who had a portrait and green tint pitching variation
2011 is Joakim Soria - the one on eBay is a portrait - if it exits, look for the matching green tint pitching variation
there is a confirmed pitching pose variation here.
#163 unconfirmed
1962 is the Hot Corners Guardians card featuring Billy Gardner and Cletis Boyer. There was a simple green tint here.
2011 is also Hot Corners Guardias, and features Alex Rodriguez and Mark Teixeira. The variation has "Hot Corners Guardians" in yellow print, instead of the base card's red, and is also missing the Heritage watermark. As no green tints have surfaced on eBay that I can find, I'm unsure whether this is a SSP or the intended green tint.
#174
1962 was Carl Willey, who could be found with and without a cap (yay, another green tint pose variation!)
2011 is Jon Garland - the one on eBay doesn't have a hat - if it exists, the variation should be a green tint "with hat"
Garland's tint variation is cropped slightly different. On the base card, none of the Dodgers script on the front of the jersey is visible. In the green tint, some of it is.
#176
1962 was Eddie Yost, who had a batting and portrait variation (one a green tint)
2011 is Chase Headley. The one on eBay shows him holding a bat - if it exists, the variation should be a green tint portrait
the tint variations still show him with bat on shoulder, but at a different angle, more of a side view
#190
1962 was Lee Walls, who had a portrait and a green tint batting pose
2011 is a shaggy-ass Todd Helton. The one on eBay is the portrait, which means a batting green tint might be out there.
confirmed frontal bat on shoulder variation
#192
1962 was another checklist card. There was a very subtle difference here. One said, "checklist, 3" and the other said, "checklist 3" (no comma)
2011 is the Marlins team card. Look for another subtle difference, I'd guess
#192 is the Marlins team card - like the #132 Angels team card, it has a simple green tint parallel
#279 confirmed
1962 was Hobie Landrith. The back of Hobie Landrith's card had the word "hobby" instead of "hitting" - it was an uncorrected error.
2011 is Bengie Molina. Look for the same thing on the back of his card.
edit: Topps confirmed a SSP for Molina. The SSP has him being born in 1994, rather than 1974.
#392 confirmed
1962 was Ken Boyer's All Star card. On the cards back, Topps gave him a batting average of .392 - in '61 he batted .329. Again, this was uncorrected.
2011 is Ryan Zimmerman's All Star card. Topps may have done something similar with Zimmeran's stats. Zimmerman batted .307 last year, so a variation where he batted .370 might be out there.
edit: Topps has confirmed that a SSP exists with Zimmerman's batting average as .370
#478 confirmed
1962 was Don Zimmer, who was pictured as a Met, but identified on the card front as a "Cin. Reds" player.
2011 is David Wright, who has both a base SP as a Met, and a confirmed SSP as a Red.
#490 confirmed
1962 was Clete Boyer, who had an uncorrected reverse negative error.
2011 is Alex Rodriguez, who also has a reverse negative as a SSP.
I'll keep this thread updated as new information comes out. If I get a wild hair, I might even throw in some pictures.
The following compiles what is known about this year's Heritage, plus what is pure speculation on my part based on the original '62. If anyone can confirm something I've written is either correct or incorrect, I'd sure appreciate it. I'll update as new information trickles in. It's entirely possible that more is out there that is nowhere on this list.
* base Short Prints are 426-500.
* tinted variations. Green tints are not SSPs, but definitely rare. Red tints are exclusive to Target, while blue tints are exclusive to Wal-Mart. They can only be found on cards numbered 110-196.
* black bordered cards. Looks like these parallel the chrome cards, and are unnumbered. They are only available from Target's 3-pack rack packages.
* green refractors. These were inserted in hobby boxes. These boxes were inserted one per case - each pack in these boxes contains one green refractor. They are not numbered.
The Super Short Prints are becoming clearer, but some of the info below is still speculation. I based all of it on quirks that exist within the original '62 set.
#129
1962 was Lee Walls - he can be found looking both right and left. His looking left pose was also a green tint.
2011 is Carlos Quentin - if it exists, look for a looking left pose variation with a green tint
at this point, I don't see that a pose variation exists. The tint variations on eBay show the same portrait as the base card.
#132
1962 was the Angels team card - one variation had two floating heads inset in the photo
2011 is, guess what, the Angels team card. Hmm
confirmed as a simple green tint - lame, in my opinion. It would have been nice to have the two floating heads. Perhaps it exists as a SSP, though.
#134
1962 was Billy Hoeft, who had two poses. These poses weren't very distinct, but the regular one had a very distinct blue sky, while the green tint had... a green sky.
2011 is Brett Cecil - the one on eBay has has a VERY distinct blue sky. Hmm, guess we should be looking for a green sky, huh?
Cecil's green tint is a full frontal portrait, as opposed to the base card's somewhat side-view portrait
#139
1962 had four total variations: two poses of Hal Reniff (pitching & portrait - one a green tint) and two poses of Ruth (one a green tint). For the record, Reniff is also #159. Fun, huh?
2011 has a Joba, a Ruth, a Jackie, and probably another Joba with a pose variation. And of course #159 is Joba.
It has been confirmed that there are four different #139s this year, too. Babe has a base and a green tint, and Joba has a different pose than his base #139 - that pose is available as a regular card and a green tint. Both are SSPed.
#147
1962 was Bill Kunkel, who had a portrait and green tint pitching variation
2011 is Joakim Soria - the one on eBay is a portrait - if it exits, look for the matching green tint pitching variation
there is a confirmed pitching pose variation here.
#163 unconfirmed
1962 is the Hot Corners Guardians card featuring Billy Gardner and Cletis Boyer. There was a simple green tint here.
2011 is also Hot Corners Guardias, and features Alex Rodriguez and Mark Teixeira. The variation has "Hot Corners Guardians" in yellow print, instead of the base card's red, and is also missing the Heritage watermark. As no green tints have surfaced on eBay that I can find, I'm unsure whether this is a SSP or the intended green tint.
#174
1962 was Carl Willey, who could be found with and without a cap (yay, another green tint pose variation!)
2011 is Jon Garland - the one on eBay doesn't have a hat - if it exists, the variation should be a green tint "with hat"
Garland's tint variation is cropped slightly different. On the base card, none of the Dodgers script on the front of the jersey is visible. In the green tint, some of it is.
#176
1962 was Eddie Yost, who had a batting and portrait variation (one a green tint)
2011 is Chase Headley. The one on eBay shows him holding a bat - if it exists, the variation should be a green tint portrait
the tint variations still show him with bat on shoulder, but at a different angle, more of a side view
#190
1962 was Lee Walls, who had a portrait and a green tint batting pose
2011 is a shaggy-ass Todd Helton. The one on eBay is the portrait, which means a batting green tint might be out there.
confirmed frontal bat on shoulder variation
#192
1962 was another checklist card. There was a very subtle difference here. One said, "checklist, 3" and the other said, "checklist 3" (no comma)
2011 is the Marlins team card. Look for another subtle difference, I'd guess
#192 is the Marlins team card - like the #132 Angels team card, it has a simple green tint parallel
#279 confirmed
1962 was Hobie Landrith. The back of Hobie Landrith's card had the word "hobby" instead of "hitting" - it was an uncorrected error.
2011 is Bengie Molina. Look for the same thing on the back of his card.
edit: Topps confirmed a SSP for Molina. The SSP has him being born in 1994, rather than 1974.
#392 confirmed
1962 was Ken Boyer's All Star card. On the cards back, Topps gave him a batting average of .392 - in '61 he batted .329. Again, this was uncorrected.
2011 is Ryan Zimmerman's All Star card. Topps may have done something similar with Zimmeran's stats. Zimmerman batted .307 last year, so a variation where he batted .370 might be out there.
edit: Topps has confirmed that a SSP exists with Zimmerman's batting average as .370
#478 confirmed
1962 was Don Zimmer, who was pictured as a Met, but identified on the card front as a "Cin. Reds" player.
2011 is David Wright, who has both a base SP as a Met, and a confirmed SSP as a Red.
#490 confirmed
1962 was Clete Boyer, who had an uncorrected reverse negative error.
2011 is Alex Rodriguez, who also has a reverse negative as a SSP.
0
Comments
#139 Joba Chamberlain (with the base #159 pose) and Babe Ruth - there may be a further cropping variation for the Babe
#163 Hot Corner Guardians - I'm not yet convinced this is anything but a regular green tint variation. Keith Olbermann and a couple others apparently feel differently
#279 Bengie Molina - correct birthday is July 20, 1974. The SSP has his birthdate as July 20, 1994
#392 Ryan Zimmerman - the base card has his correct batting average listed as .307, while the SSP has him batting .370
#478 David Wright: base SP Mets and SSP Reds
#490 Alex Rodriguez: reverse negative SSP and base SP
Dodgers collection scans | Brett Butler registry | 1978 Dodgers - straight 9s, homie
Now collecting:
Topps Heritage
1957 Topps BB Ex+-NM
All Yaz Items 7+
Various Red Sox
Did I leave anything out?
Dodgers collection scans | Brett Butler registry | 1978 Dodgers - straight 9s, homie
Topps Heritage 2001-Now
Topps Heritage Blue Autos (2016-2022)
#111 Brad Lidge
#112 Luke Scott
#113 White Sox team card
#114 Kyle Drabek
#115 Alfonso Soriano
#116 Gavin Floyd
#117 Alex Rios
#118 Skip Schumaker
#119 Scott Cousins
120 Bronson Arroyo
121 Buck Showalter
122 Trevor Cahill
123 Aaron Hill
Dodgers collection scans | Brett Butler registry | 1978 Dodgers - straight 9s, homie
i will say the green tint makes the cards look just awful lol.
have fun with all the variations!
Topps Heritage - Trade Page
<< <i>Geordi, are there black variations that are not black refractors? yet they still mirror the chrome set? >>
Jim, that is indeed the case. I think the black bordered cards come out of Wal-Mart packs? Can someone verify that for me, please?
Dodgers collection scans | Brett Butler registry | 1978 Dodgers - straight 9s, homie
My Registry Sets
Dodgers collection scans | Brett Butler registry | 1978 Dodgers - straight 9s, homie
<< <i>
<< <i>Geordi, are there black variations that are not black refractors? yet they still mirror the chrome set? >>
Jim, that is indeed the case. I think the black bordered cards come out of Wal-Mart packs? Can someone verify that for me, please? >>
the black border cards came from the middle pack. I got them from Target, not sure if Walmart has them. John
Current obsession, all things Topps 1969 - 1972
Always looking for Topps Salesman Samples, pre '51 unopened packs, E90-2, E91a, N690 Kalamazoo Bats, and T204 Square Frame Ramly's
Dodgers collection scans | Brett Butler registry | 1978 Dodgers - straight 9s, homie
Always looking for Topps Salesman Samples, pre '51 unopened packs, E90-2, E91a, N690 Kalamazoo Bats, and T204 Square Frame Ramly's
Save on ebay with Big Crumbs
<< <i>yes red tints only come from gravity single packs at a rate of 1:11 packs. Blue tint the same for walmart. >>
Are they exclusive to the 110-196 numbers or do they parallel the entire set?
What I'm selling
Building Sets, Collecting Texas Rangers, and Texas Tech Red Raiders
Dodgers collection scans | Brett Butler registry | 1978 Dodgers - straight 9s, homie
Now collecting:
Topps Heritage
1957 Topps BB Ex+-NM
All Yaz Items 7+
Various Red Sox
Did I leave anything out?
My Sandberg topps basic set
My Sandberg Topps Master set
The six SSPs (four of which had already been sniffed out)
– #490 Alex Rodriguez (reversed negative)
– #478 David Wright (Cin. Reds listed on front)
– #139 Joba Chamberlain (appears on a version of card No. 139)
– #279 Bengie Molina (Wrong birthday on back)
– #392 Ryan Zimmerman (batting average incorrect on back)
– #125 Vladimir Guerrero (listed as a pitcher on the back)
I need to find clear pictures of Molina, Zimmerman and Guerrero now.
Dodgers collection scans | Brett Butler registry | 1978 Dodgers - straight 9s, homie
I might try again, they had two more there.
Edited to add:
Did pull a Phillies team card so I was happy about that.
Dodgers collection scans | Brett Butler registry | 1978 Dodgers - straight 9s, homie
<< <i>#125 Vladimir Guerrero - listed as a pitcher on the back - this card has zero relationship with the original '62 set.
I think this is a throwback to the 1962 card #521. It listed Phillies outfielder Jacke Davis as a pitcher on the back. Since Topps probably won't print a 2011 Heritage high number set beyond #500, they reversed the #521 to #125 and viola!
<< <i>
<< <i>#125 Vladimir Guerrero - listed as a pitcher on the back - this card has zero relationship with the original '62 set.
I think this is a throwback to the 1962 card #521. It listed Phillies outfielder Jacke Davis as a pitcher on the back. Since Topps probably won't print a 2011 Heritage high number set beyond #500, they reversed the #521 to #125 and viola! >>
you are absolutely right - good catch!
Dodgers collection scans | Brett Butler registry | 1978 Dodgers - straight 9s, homie
Thanks again,
Bob
email bcmiller7@comcast.net