Options
Question on 2 early original dollars with an "issue"
TPRC
Posts: 3,819 ✭✭✭✭✭
I have been thinking of buying 2 1795 dollars, one flowing hair, the other a small eagle, both fairly but "market" priced, both common varieties, both very pleasing and original, both PCGS vg-10, both from the same collection, but each with an "issue." An associate (and former grader) looked at both and made a couple of interesting comments to me so I thought I would solicit opinions. I should stress that these are very pleasing looking coins in hand. I graded them vg-10 when raw but others I respect thought they would go at least a f-12. There was never a question as to whether PCGS would grade them.
The flowing hair dollar has a planchet lamination error, which cannot be seen without a glass but which is not exactly small. It is kind of like a long zig-zag, with one zig in the field in front of the face, a smaller one on the cheek and a still smaller one on the neck. It sounds bad but it is impossible to see without a glass and the coin is very pleasing. It really hadn't bothered me when I saw first saw it. The associate who looked at it thought it added to the interest and attractiveness of the coin.
The small eagle dollar has roughness in the obverse and reverse fields. The devices are terrific and the overall look of the coin is super original. I wondered if it was corrosion but the devices are so nice that problem is definitely in the pre-strike planchet. The associate didn't like this issue on this coin.
These coins are original and that is a plus but I am now inclined to wait to find coins that are actually choice for the grade and without "issues." It's not as if no more of these coins exist. In addition, I always heard that minor errors (clips, etc.) in early date coins generally detracted from their value, unless major.
Your comments are appreciated.
The flowing hair dollar has a planchet lamination error, which cannot be seen without a glass but which is not exactly small. It is kind of like a long zig-zag, with one zig in the field in front of the face, a smaller one on the cheek and a still smaller one on the neck. It sounds bad but it is impossible to see without a glass and the coin is very pleasing. It really hadn't bothered me when I saw first saw it. The associate who looked at it thought it added to the interest and attractiveness of the coin.
The small eagle dollar has roughness in the obverse and reverse fields. The devices are terrific and the overall look of the coin is super original. I wondered if it was corrosion but the devices are so nice that problem is definitely in the pre-strike planchet. The associate didn't like this issue on this coin.
These coins are original and that is a plus but I am now inclined to wait to find coins that are actually choice for the grade and without "issues." It's not as if no more of these coins exist. In addition, I always heard that minor errors (clips, etc.) in early date coins generally detracted from their value, unless major.
Your comments are appreciated.
Tom
0
Comments
R.I.P. Bear
PCGS Registries
Box of 20
SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
Tom
AJ
PCGS Registries
Box of 20
SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
www.brunkauctions.com
That said, if pushed, I would answer exactly opposite of RYK
Of course, we would all prefer to see the coins in hand (or pics) and make a more informed recommendation, and (thankfully so!) we all have our own tastes on subjective "issues".
I hope this helps & good luck with your decision...Mike
<< <i>Here is mine. I want to upgrade, but it will be hard to let this one go because the surfaces are so nice.
AJ >>
Beautiful!
Tom